Secretary - Movie Review
Rating: 4 out of 5
Secret desires and dark, unusual fetishes make for great fiction, but few filmmakers have enough courage to tackle ideas that private. However, Steven Shainberg has more than enough audacity and he doesn't hesitate to push the envelope way beyond the norm with his new movie Secretary, a film which appropriately won a Special Jury Prize for originality at Sundance.
Secretary explodes with juicy innuendo, even from its opening moments. An extending establishing shot plays against mischievously sensual music as a woman seductively strolls through a business office performing secretarial duties. She approaches a desk, staples a few papers, pours fresh coffee into a mug, and then returns to her employer. Sounds ordinary, except that she does these things while locked inside a weird S&M device.
This is Lee Holloway (Maggie Gyllenhaal), the very troubled daughter of an alcoholic father and an abused mother. Watching the abusive relationships between her parents for so many years, Lee now inflicts cuts on herself in an attempt to let the pain surface. Apparently, it hasn't helped enough; she just returned from a mental institution after an attempted suicide.
Lee wants to get her life back on track, so she applies for a secretarial job at a local law firm owned by E. Edward Grey (James Spader). She has no work experience but can type really fast. Interestingly enough, that's all that Grey requires and he hires her on the spot. But Grey senses something else about Lee: she seeks physical pain and needs to be controlled. Ironically, Grey needs control and enjoys inflicting physical pain on others. Don't they just make the perfect pair?
Inevitably, Grey and Holloway begin a relationship that crosses far beyond the legal lines of conduct. Holloway could probably sue Grey for everything that he's worth if she didn't enjoy it when her boss swatted her ass.
The instant Lee and Grey meet, they create awkwardness unlike anything I've ever seen. The characters are linked by bizarre sexual desires, but Secretary knows that their private obsessions are far more interesting than the lazy intercourse most sex comedies resort to at the first opportunity. Secretary explores sexuality in a completely unique and innovative light. And it's amazing how long it resists actual sex until just the right moment; it might actually wait too long.
There's a point when the movie falls apart, and, ironically, that's at the climax of Lee and Grey's relationship. It's almost as if the writer could no longer maintain the stunning tension Spader and Gyllenhaal sustain so effectively through most of the film. Secretary builds to the climax extraordinarily well, but it reaches the peak too early. This is the last film on the planet that I expected to evolve into a conventional love story, but sure enough...
By this point, however, it's too late for the movie to crash and burn, because it has already created an insuperable relationship between the audience and its characters. The film loses the battle for the third act, but it easily wins the overall war.
On a side note, this movie fought to secure its R rating (that it earned for "strong sexuality, some nudity, depiction of behavioral disorders, and language"). Strange how some movies overflow with gratuitous sex and nudity and easily earn an R, but this one, which resists that very same sexual content, struggles to nab the same rating. But I will give the MPAA kudos for including that bit on "behavioral disorders." Man, these characters are psycho!
A nice commentary from director Shainberg and writer Erin Wilson anchors the DVD -- it's full of info not just about the filmmaking process but about the characters' motivations (and the filmmakers' too!). Alas, no Maggie on the commentary track...
Heel, Maggie.
Facts and Figures
Year: 2002
Run time: 104 mins
In Theaters: Thursday 14th November 2002
Box Office USA: $3.8M
Box Office Worldwide: $9.3M
Distributed by: Lions Gate
Production compaines: Slough Pond, double A Films
Reviews
Contactmusic.com: 4 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 75%
Fresh: 107 Rotten: 36
IMDB: 7.1 / 10
Cast & Crew
Director: Steven Shainberg
Producer: Andrew Fierberg, Amy Hobby, Steven Shainberg
Screenwriter: Erin Cressida Wilson
Starring: James Spader as E. Edward Grey, Maggie Gyllenhaal as Lee Holloway, Jeremy Davies as Peter, Lesley Ann Warren as Joan Holloway, Stephen McHattie as Burt Holloway, Amy Locane as Lee's Sister, Patrick Bauchau as Dr. Twardon, Jessica Tuck as Tricia O'Connor, Oz Perkins as Jonathan
Also starring: Andrew Fierberg, Amy Hobby, Steven Shainberg, Erin Cressida Wilson