The New York college student, 21, alleges he spent the night with the pop babe last summer (03) after partying with Spears, her backing dancer CHARISSA SEAMAN and her boyfriend JOSH CLEPHAS at a Santa Barbara, California beach.
After a naked swim in the sea, the foursome returned to the FOUR SEASONS HOTEL for music and games, before Seaman told Witchey her famous pal wanted to sleep with him.
Witchey tells British magazine MORE!, "When we were lying there after, she told me I was her second one night stand.
"Then she told me about her relationship with her dance arranger Wade Robson, which broke up her and Justin Timberlake."
Spears and Timberlake ended their three-year relationship in March 2001.
Although both have refused to discuss the reason behind the split, Timberlake's hit song CRY ME A RIVER featured a Spears lookalike and lyrics about a cheating girlfriend.
The lyrics include, "You don't have to say, what you did. I already know, I found out from him."07/05/2004 17:36
With clips from more than 200 teen movies made in the decade after 1995's Clueless,...
The cameo-driven, "Mission: Impossible 2"-spoofing, movie-within-a-movie, pre-title sequence of "Austin Powers in Goldmember" is the...