Why Have American Idol Ratings Dropped? - Comments and Message Board

Comments Return to Article

KartofflMuter's picture

KartofflMuter

I'd like to add,the only judge who had "checked in" for duty IMHO and I've seen every season except season 1,was Mariah. She gave people have a chance,like the the clueless Sikh at the end.Personally,I hope he gets a lot more chances. His singing was brief but capable of of switching from classical forms to modern ones. I think some judges might be surprised just how much breath control those long classical phrases take and how much more power his lungs have that he was unaware that they wanted from him. I listen to this music frequently and rarely with microphones. The singers never need them and are used to performing in halls that don't have them.Jackson was as useless as usual. I was glad when I read he was leaving. Why is he back? And Keith seems too not connect with Randy and to fear the 2 women. This is not good.

1 year 3 months ago
Report
View Comments

KartofflMuter's picture

KartofflMuter

It's unwatchable? I recorded it and made it through the recording in 15 minutes. The cat fights? Not amused. The pity-party back stories-"1 have 35 year life expectancy.I was a dancer for 17 years till they cut off my leg.My parents are watching but I really can't sing..."-oh yes and the first "find",the girl who added so many frills I longed for Simon to say "shut up" instead of praise her. But no. So happy to find someone on pitch, they offered her the crown 15 minutes into Day one. Should I laugh or cry. Minaj wasn't wearing the clown wig yet so -let's go with cry. Clay Aiken. Where are you? I miss your wit,charm,intelligence,and dare we say it? I miss your voice.

1 year 3 months ago
Report
View Comments