Movie Reviews War Horse

Most film critics take a cold, analytical approach to what they see on the screen, and if the movie stirs deep emotions, they are likely to ascribe that reaction to "manipulation" by the director. Such is the case with Steven Spielberg's War Horse , in both positive and negative reviews, as if manipulation were not the business of a director. Going into virtually any dramatic film that focuses on an animal, a moviegoer generally knows that they're in for an emotional experience, and several critics agree that Spielberg is a master at making that experience intense and often cathartic. "You may find yourself resisting this sentimental pageant," writes A.O. Scott in the New York Times, "but my strong advice is to surrender. ... Quiet the snarky voice in your head and allow yourself to recall, or perhaps to discover, the deep pleasures of sincerity." In the Chicago Sun-Times Roger Ebert writes that he believes the movie is a homage "to a Hollywood tradition of broad, uplifting movies intended for all audiences. ... War Horse is bold, not afraid of sentiment and lets out all the stops in magnificently staged action sequences. Its characters are clearly defined and strongly played by charismatic actors." Finally, he concludes, "The film is made with superb artistry." Indeed, Kyle Smith sums up in the New York Post "Those who say they don't make 'em like they used to must now fall silent." Mick LaSalle in the San Francisco Chronicle is obviously of two minds about the movie. "As messy as it is inspired," he observes, "it jumps from episode to episode, lurching unexpectedly to life -- more entertaining than it seemingly should be and, all the while, making you feel things, whether you want to or not." Likewise, Claudia Puig in USA Today begins her review by complaining about the 2 1/2-hour length of the movie ("a long slog"), faulting it for "obvious sentimentality," and sometimes "clichéd" dialogue. But for all of that, she concludes, " War Horse has an exhilarating, impressionistic beauty, and emotion trumps rationality at every turn." In the end, she predicts, it "will likely take its place alongside beloved family films." The headline on Steven Rea's review in the Philadelphia Inquirer seems at odds with his actual opinion of the movie. "Bloody, sugary, tear-jerker of a tale about a horse and a boy," reads the headline. But in his review, Rea writes " War Horse is sugary, to be sure -- but it is sugar cut with cannon fire and barbed wire and the horrors of war." The Associated Press's Christie Lemire likes the movie's "holiday feel-goodery," but writes that the dialogue "might just make you cringe." But Rex Reed in the New York Observer has no reservations about the movie, writing, "You will not believe the epic splendor, sweeping drama and heart-stopping passion [Spielberg] brings to War Horse . It's a rare and genuine movie masterpiece that deserves the label in a thousand ways."

23/12/2011


Contactmusic

Tags: The New York Times - Drama - Rex Reed - Roger Ebert - The Horrors


Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

Contrary To Her Song Lyrics, Lana Del Rey Worked Her Way To The Top

Lana Del Rey is no stranger to vicious rumours, but she definitely did not...

Contrary To Her Song Lyrics, Lana Del Rey Worked Her Way To The Top

Weird Al Scores First U.S Number 1 With New Album

The album was released only one week ago and sold 103,000 copies to secure the top...

Weird Al Scores First U.S Number 1 With New Album

Peaches Geldof's Cause of Death Confirmed as Heroin Overdose

The second daughter of musician Bob Geldof, Peaches Geldof was thrust...

Peaches Geldof's Cause of Death Confirmed as Heroin Overdose

Robert Downey Jr.IS Iron Man... But For How Long?

You know who he is. Robert Downey Jr.’s involvement in the Iron Man franchise has been...

Robert Downey Jr.IS Iron Man... But For How Long?

Hercules Extended Trailer

Following his deadly ordeal of being put through the Twelve Labours by his father Zeus and his...

Hercules Trailer

Miley Cyrus Appears in Pharrell's New Video 'Come Get It Bae'

Cyrus also features on the track's vocals, and -perhaps most shockingly of all- resists...

Miley Cyrus Appears in Pharrell's New Video 'Come Get It Bae'
Advertisement

That Time Snoop Dogg Puffed Mary Jane at The White House

Snoop Dogg has joined Willie Nelson as weed-loving musicians who have smoked...

That Time Snoop Dogg Puffed Mary Jane at The White House

Gershwinner: Our Top 5 Billy Joel Songs

Billy Joel has long been regarded as one of music’s finest songwriters but it will soon be all more official...

Gershwinner: Our Top 5 Billy Joel Songs

Rob Reiner's 'And So It Goes' Is A Safe Bet At The Cinema This Weekend

Fresh from the critical and box office success of Behind The Candelabra, for...

Rob Reiner's 'And So It Goes' Is A Safe Bet At The Cinema This Weekend


More recommendations

Advertisement

Comments

The New York Times Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on The New York Times

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All