Movie Reviews The Thing

They're calling the third rendition of The Thing , a prequel, but most critics indicate that there's not much difference in the plot between the earlier Thing s and this one (including, obviously, the title). Several maintain that this version is no improvement on the earlier ones. David Germain of the Associated Press argues that "the new Thing kind of does what the alien does -- digest the original and spit out a creepy copy whose sole purpose is to survive at any cost. There's not much suspense, and the few scares are cheap jolts that could have come from any old monster movie." Jeannette Catsoulis in the New York Times adds, "Where the earlier film pulsed with precisely calibrated paranoia and distinctly drawn characters, this inarticulate replay unfolds as mechanistically as a video game." And Roger Moore comments in the Orlando Sentinel "Try to forget the earlier, superior versions of the tale. This Thing still doesn't deliver much more than the odd jolt or provoke any praise other than 'Cool effects.'" Actually, the movie is drawing quite a bit of praise. Michael Phillips in the Chicago Tribune writes that this version "engaged me more than Carpenter's," and Joe Neumaier in the New York Daily News observes that the point of going to see such a movie is "to jump out of our skins. And the narrow corridors and shallow focus are perfect for wondering what's behind the corners. In terms of scares, this old-fashioned Thing is better than most new things." And Tom Russo in the Boston Globe remarks that "Dutch director Matthijs van Heijningen and company deliver lean suspense, and they update the Carpenter crew's gnarly alien-shapeshifter effects skillfully enough to remind us why the concept captures geek imaginations." But Roger Ebert in the Chicago Sun-Times suggests that perhaps there is just too much technical skill exhibited here. "The more you see of a monster, the less you get. It is the unseen, the imagined, that scares you. This version ... provides such graphic and detailed views of the creature that we are essentially reduced to looking at special effects, and being aware that we are."

14/10/2011


Contactmusic

Tags: The New York Times - Michael Phillips - Roger Ebert - Roger Moore - Skins - The Unseen


Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

"Hercules" Falters, While "Lucy" Shines At The Box Office With $44 Million

This week at the box office, the sci-fi thriller Lucy won out over slim...

The New Mockingjay Trailer Will Make Your Heart Weep

Another Comic-Con, another Hunger Games trailer. Not that we mind, of course...

The New Mockingjay Trailer Will Make Your Heart Weep

Director George Miller Speaks On Purposely Avoiding Use Of CGI In 'Mad Max: Fury Road'

It has been over three decades since Australian filmmaker...

Director George Miller Speaks On Purposely Avoiding Use Of CGI In 'Mad Max: Fury Road'

Taylor Swift Offers Advice To A Young Fan With A Broken Heart

If her songs are anything to go by, then Taylor Swift is definitely the person you should...

 Taylor Swift Offers Advice To A Young Fan With A Broken Heart

Over 20 Fans Hospitalized Following Keith Urban's Weekend Concert

For many concertgoers, Keith Urban's Saturday night (July 26th) show in...

Over 20 Fans Hospitalized Following Keith Urban's Weekend Concert

Aretha Franklin Lashes Out At Canadian Fast Food Join For Showing Her No Respect

Legendary singer Aretha Franklin has publically scolded an employee at...

Aretha Franklin Lashes Out At Canadian Fast Food Join For Showing Her No Respect
Advertisement

Flirt Alert: Did Orlando Bloom And Nina Dobrev Really Get Close At Comic-Con?

Ok, so the romance at Comic-Con is definitely secondary to the first...

Flirt Alert: Did Orlando Bloom And Nina Dobrev Really Get Close At Comic-Con?

Nicki Minaj Announces Postponement Of New Single 'Anaconda' With Sexy Swimsuit Pic

Nicki Minaj managed to garner the attention of an undoubtedly...

Nicki Minaj Announces Postponement Of New Single 'Anaconda' With Sexy Swimsuit Pic

Comic-Con Update: Evangeline Lilly Joins The Cast Of Ant-Man Amid Production Mishaps

More Marvel. More cast announcements. This is Comic-Con weekend. The latest round...

Comic-Con Update: Evangeline Lilly Joins The Cast Of Ant-Man Amid Production Mishaps


More recommendations

Advertisement

Comments

The New York Times Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on The New York Times

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All