Movie Reviews Shutter Island

Most critics -- but hardly all -- appear to agree that while Shutter Island may not rank with some of the greatest Martin Scorsese masterworks, it belongs well up there. As John Anderson puts it in the Wall Street Journal "It won't be a beloved movie. It will inspire doctoral dissertations. And while this news may not bring unbridled joy to the folks at Paramount Pictures, let them be consoled by the thought that it possesses a kind of obsessive perfection." Chris Vognar in the Dallas Morning News writes that the movie "rattles your cage and leaves you fumbling for a firm place to stand. It entangles illusion and perception, sanity and madness as only pure cinema can; you leave the theater a bit jittery and unsettled." Lisa Kennedy in the Denver Post describes it as "a vastly intelligent movie ... a heady thriller." Lou Lumenick in the New York Post suggests that Scorsese is taking "a breather from prestige pictures" to turn out "an exquisitely crafted potboiler, offering up 2 1/2 hours of thrills." And Betsy Sharkey in the Los Angeles Times writes that "Scorsese has given us a new noir classic." But the criticism of the film is equally profuse. "Classy, well-acted junk," is the way Michael Phillips describes it in the Chicago Tribune. A.O. Scott in the New York Times says that it's "illuminated with flashes of virtuosity but with no particular heat, conviction or purpose." Peter Howell begins his review in the Toronto Star by remarking, "'If you're going to fail, fail big,' the old saying goes, and that's just about the only positive thing that can be said about Shutter Island , Martin Scorsese's elephantine exercise in B-movie badness." And Mick LaSalle in the San Francisco Chronicle figures "If Martin Scorsese weren't aware of himself as a great filmmaker, he could never have made a movie as bad as Shutter Island ."

19/02/2010


Contactmusic

Tags: Chicago - John Anderson - Madness - Martin Scorsese - Paramount Pictures


Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

Why ‘The House of Magic’ Is The Movie To Go See This Weekend

If you’re looking for a cinematic treat for all the family this weekend, then...

Why ‘The House of Magic’ Is The Movie To Go See This Weekend

Here Comes Guardians of The Galaxy, A Huge Weekend in Store?

‘Guardians of The Galaxy’ hits cinemas next weekend with Marvel...

Here Comes Guardians of The Galaxy, A Huge Weekend in Store?

Bastille - Flaws [Live]

Bastille perform their 2012 single 'Flaws' live at The Troubadour in London to an enthusiastic crowd. The...

Bastille - Flaws [Live] Video

Colbie Caillat - Try Single Review

Colbie Caillat isn't known for producing 'trendy' pop songs of any kind, but she certainly always maintains...

Colbie Caillat - Try Single Review

'The Purge: Anarchy' Launches Another Grisly Franchise

Last year's sleeper hit The Purge was an unusually intelligent thriller starring Ethan Hawke as...

'The Purge: Anarchy' Launches Another Grisly Franchise

Nightcrawler Trailer

Lou Bloom is a hard-working budding journalist whose deep obsession with his career has rendered him...

Nightcrawler Trailer
Advertisement

'Joe' Is A Reminder That Nicolas Cage is a Great Actor

There are all kinds of theories about Nicolas Cage's acting style, usually centred on whether...

'Joe' Is A Reminder That Nicolas Cage is a Great Actor

Blunt, Mirren or Winslet? Who Will Win Best Actress Oscar 2015?

The biggest night in the film award circuit is still seven months away. But...

Blunt, Mirren or Winslet? Who Will Win Best Actress Oscar 2015?

Legendary Rocker Tom Petty Returns With New Album 'Hypnotic Eyes'

American rock legend Tom Petty reunites with backing band The Heartbreakers...

Legendary Rocker Tom Petty Returns With New Album 'Hypnotic Eyes'


More recommendations

Advertisement

Comments

Chicago Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Chicago

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All