Movie Reviews J. Edgar

In an apparent effort to stir up word-of-mouth for a difficult film to market, Warner Bros. is releasing the controversial J. Edgar , starring Leonardo Di Caprio, today, in advance of the Veterans Day weekend. The film was directed by Clint Eastwood, who himself has called it one of his "anti-tentpole" movies, referring to the big-budget productions usually released during the summer or the December holidays that are expected to earn hundreds of millions of dollars. What J. Edgar , a biopic about former FBI chief J. Edgar Hoover, has earned so far is a bundle of stellar reviews. Writing in the New York Times , Manohla Dargis concludes, "Mr. Eastwood explores the inner life of a lonely man whose fortress was also his stage. From there, surrounded by a few trusted souls, he played out a fiction in which he was as heroic as a James Cagney G-man (despite a life with a mother Norman Bates would recognize), but finally as weak, compromised and human as those whose lives he helped crush." Lou Lumenick in the New York Post forecasts that DiCaprio's performance as Hoover "should put him in the running for an Oscar," calling it a "tour de force." Joe Neumaier in the New York Daily News writes that DiCaprio's "portrayal of Hoover is undeniably terrific." The film explores the many rumors about Hoover's personal life -- carefully. Clearly it shows him in a close relationship with Clyde Tolson, his assistant, with whom some say he had a homosexual relationship. But as Kenneth Turan in the Los Angeles Times observes, "At this point in time, the truth is unknowable. Black's persuasive script posits that the men definitely had strong feelings for each other but that Hoover, at least, could not even acknowledge, let alone act on them." The film is being hailed by other critics for its Citizen Kane -like photography and for Eastwood's decision to use talented makeup artists to age his characters, rather than resort to computers. "As a period biopic, J. Edgar is masterful," writes Roger Ebert in the Chicago Sun Times . "Few films span seven decades this comfortably." There are a handful of negative reviews, including Mick LaSalle's in the San Francisco Chronicle which judges the film to be a "grand disappointment." And Rex Reed in the New York Observer calls it "boring and ineffectual. There's no passion behind it."



Tags: Leonardo Dicaprio - Clint Eastwood - FBI - James Cagney - Rex Reed - Roger Ebert - The New York Times


More Leonardo Dicaprio

Leonardo DiCaprio To Tackle Gorilla Poachers In New Netflix Documentary ‘Virunga’

Netflix has scored again with another high profile star, with the streaming service announcing it's teaming up with Leonardo DiCaprio to release a new documentary....

Christian Bale to Play Steve Jobs after Leonardo DiCaprio Passes

Christian Bale will play the late Apple founder Steve Jobs in Sony's forthcoming biopic, sources confirm. The project boasts a huge pedigree with Danny Boyle...

Andre 3000 Wants Leonardo DiCaprio To Play Him. Which Could Be Problematic.

Andre 3000 may have just played Jimi Hendrix in Jimi: All Is By My Side, but the Outkast man has some ambitious plans for a...

Andre 3000 Has Some Interesting Casting Ideas For An Outkast Movie

Andre 3000 has some interesting ideas about who he might cast if there were to be a movie about Outkast, and you probably won't have...


Leonardo DiCaprio Addresses Word Leaders In First U.N. Speech On Climate Change

Earlier last week Leonardo DiCaprio was bestowed with the title of Messenger of Peace by the United Nations, and on Tuesday (Sept 23rd), the 39...

Leonardo DiCaprio Named Messenger Of Peace By United Nations

Leonardo DiCaprio has earned many awards and honours throughout his famed movie career, but his most recent accolade may eclipse them all due to the...

'Django Unchained' Actress 'Handcuffed After Kissing Companion'

Daniele Watts, the American actress who appeared in the Oscar winning movie 12 Years' a Slave, was detained by police in Los Angeles on Sunday...

De Niro, Pitt and DiCaprio Set for Martin Scorsese Short Film

In what may well be the most star-studded short movie of all time, Martin Scorsese will direct a campaign video for Melco-Crown Entertainment (MCE) starring...



Leonardo Dicaprio Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Leonardo Dicaprio

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All