Movie Reviews Dark Shadows

The critics appear equally divided over Dark Shadows , and we're referring not just to how they line up for or against the movie but also, in many cases, to how they render their individual reviews. Take Roger Ebert's in the Chicago Sun-Times , for example. He hails Johnny Depp's performance as "pitch perfect," playing the character Barnabas "with a lasered intensity." Director Tim Burton's sets and art direction are "spectacular" and offer "wonderful things," he writes, before concluding, " Dark Shadows begins with great promise, but then the energy drains out." Likewise Kenneth Turan in the Los Angeles Times praises the film's "wonderful production design" and adds that "Depp's performance is so unwavering in its commitment to eccentricity that it is hard not to be fitfully entertained." But the plot, he remarks, "is all over the place, getting more grotesque and less involving the longer it goes on, and that, as even the undead would admit, is a damned shame." Joe Morgenstern in the Wall Street Journal allows that the movie "is amusing, in fits and spurts, and sure to make tons of money, but terribly familiar and fatigued." Claudia Puig in USA Today observes that Dark Shadows "is at its best in comic mode ... but it bookends the funny stuff with run-of-the-mill special effects and action." Those are some of the glass-half-empty reviews. On the other hand, consider Mick LaSalle's review in the San Francisco Chronicle . "There are times, not too many, when the movie drags," he writes. "But when you consider all the pitfalls avoided, and all the laughs and pleasures it provides along the way, Dark Shadows is a satisfying and skillful effort." Manohla Dargis in the New York Times acknowledges that Burton "isn't big on narrative logic, coherence and thrust" and adds that " Dark Shadows isn't among Mr. Burton's most richly realized works." However, she concludes, "it's very enjoyable, visually sumptuous and, despite its lugubrious source material and a sporadic tremor of violence, surprisingly effervescent." Ty Burr in the Boston Globe also concedes that Burton's "own curse is that his knack for visual invention has always been shadowed by hapless storytelling." But he points out that his source material, the afternoon TV show, "was incoherent to start with," adding that in the case of Dark Shadows , the movie, there's just enough structure to tide us over ... but it's the atmosphere and the riffs that matter." Like other critics, Joe Neumaier in the New York Daily News faults Burton for trying to "serve too many masters" with "a soap opera season's worth of plot" but the characters are "all creepy, kooky, mysterious and spooky, and keep Dark Shadows from dying a slow death." And Lou Lumenick in the New York Post , while calling the plot of the movie "undernourished," concludes that "for all its shortcomings, I'd sooner watch a sequel to Dark Shadows than another installment of the bloated Pirates of the Caribbean saga any day."

11/05/2012


Contactmusic

Tags: The Shadows - Example - Pirates Of The Caribbean - The New York Times - Wall Street

Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

Our Tastebuds Are Tingling For This Year's Hottest New Artists

The world's biggest fast food chain presents three of the top up-and-coming indie...

Our Tastebuds Are Tingling For This Year's Hottest New Artists

Benedict Cumberbatch, Christian Bale, Cate Blanchett: Meet The Cast of Andy Serkis’s ‘The Jungle Book’

Hot on the heels of Disney announcing their star filled Jungle Book cast, Warner...

Benedict Cumberbatch, Christian Bale, Cate Blanchett: Meet The Cast of Andy Serkis’s ‘The Jungle Book’

Maroon 5 - Animals [Lyric] Video

Ahead of their fifth studio album, 'V', in September, Maroon 5 is continuing their promotion by releasing the lyric video for their...

Maroon 5 - Animals (Lyric Video) Video

God Help the Girl Movie Review

With bouncy pop tunes and a breezy tone, this Scottish musical sometimes feels so weightless that it seems to float right out...

God Help the Girl Movie Review

Reviews: 'The One I Love' - Moss and Duplass Shine

Starring Mad Men’s Elizabeth Moss, The One I Love follows Ethan (Mark Duplass) and Sophie (Moss) attempt...

Reviews: 'The One I Love' - Moss and Duplass Shine

Jennifer Lawrence in Talks with Quentin Tarantino for 'The Hateful Eight'

Jennifer Lawrenceis in negotiations withQuentin Tarantinoto star in his forthcoming...

Jennifer Lawrence in Talks with Quentin Tarantino for 'The Hateful Eight'

Miley Cyrus Banned From Performing In Dominican Republic

Miley Cyrus has been banned from performing in the Dominican Republic. The...

Miley Cyrus Banned From Performing In Dominican Republic

Chris Pratt Pays Visit To Children's Hospital As Peter Quill

The world keeps on falling in love with Chris Pratt over and over again. After a...

Chris Pratt Pays Visit To Children's Hospital As Peter Quill

Win A Pair Of Lady Gaga Heartbeats Headphones From Beats By Dre

Welcome all you eagle-eyed freebie spotters to our latest competition where...

Win A Pair Of Lady Gaga Heartbeats Headphones From Beats By Dre
Advertisement

Comments

The Shadows Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on The Shadows

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All