Movie Reviews 50/50

50/50 are the odds of surviving a rare form of cancer that the main character in the movie with those odds in the title is diagnosed with. It's loosely based on screenwriter Will Reiser's personal experiences. Given its premise the odds of its being praised by critics were probably a lot lower than those in the title. But, according to nearly all of them, 50/50 is a winner. Moviegoers will probably first turn to Roger Ebert's review in the Chicago Sun-Times to get his assessment of the movie first. After all, he's a film critic who knows a thing or two about cancer, as well as a thing or two about comedy. "Some of the comedy aspects may seem unlikely," he writes, but "if a movie like this were as relentlessly realistic as a masterpiece like Mike Nichols' Wit , it would probably not be commercial and end up, as Wit did, on HBO. A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down." Ebert concludes " 50/50 isn't completely true to life, but the more you know about cancer, the less you want it to be. ... It creates a comforting myth. That's one of the things movies are good for." Manohla Dargis in the New York Times also mentions that much of the movie deals with the main character's entry "into the land of the sick, a place that the filmmakers try to portray with real, difficult feeling while also making it as cozy and finally unthreatening as possible." "Still, it's hard to imagine moviegoers seeking out a comedy about cancer, positive critical reviews or no. Lou Lumenick in the New York Post certainly seems to sense such public reluctance. "I laughed a lot at 50/50, which has a dark sense of humor that appealed to me," he writes. "If you're offended at Patrick Swayze jokes in this context, you might not agree." The critics give much of the credit for the movie's success to the performances of Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Seth Rogen, who plays his best friend. Levitt, writes Carrie Rickey in the Philadelphia Inquirer , "is touching, funny, and fierce -- an unusual combination of moods, but deeply affecting." Rogen, who actually is writer Will Reiser's friend and stood by him during his cancer scare, also pulls off one of his best performances, the critics say. "Maybe because he's playing a version of himself in Reiser's story, he's more appealing than ever," Joe Neumaier remarks in the New York Daily News . A small number of critics were left unmoved by it all -- and Rex Reed excoriates the movie in the New York Observer. "Artificial, irresponsible, filthy and forgettable, it knocks itself cross-eyed trying to make you roar with laughter at chemotherapy," Reed thunders.

30/09/2011


Contactmusic

Tags: HBO - Joseph Gordon-Levitt - Patrick Swayze - Rex Reed - Seth Rogen - The New York Times

Advertisement

More Hbo

Rachel McAdams In 'True Detective 2' Talks & Other Cast Rumours

Rachel McAdams is rumoured to be in talks with the makers of the second series of True Detective. The 35-year-old Canadian actor is not the...

Creative Primetime Emmy Awards 2014 [Pictures]

The stars stepped out onto the red carpet for one of the glitziest ceremonies of awards season: the Creative Primetime Emmys.Having previously won for NBC's...

David Simon and HBO Get Busy Once More: 'Show Me A Hero' Announced

The beautiful union that is David Simon and HBO is to reoccur with ‘Show Me A Hero’. The man behind critically acclaimed hits like The...

Dave Goldblatt - A Facebook Employee - Is the Guy Who Paid $20k To Be in 'Game of Thrones' and Die

George R.R. Martin promised that he’d write in and gruesomely kill a new character And the winner of that Prizeo.com competition was Dave Goldblatt, a...

Advertisement

Look Out Spotify – Amazon Launches Audio Streaming Service ‘Prime Music’

Amazon is tipping it toe into the saturated online music streaming business by launching ‘Prime Music’ – its own service that will be available free...

Game of Thrones vs. The Sopranos: Is Popularity Indicative of Quality?

The inevitable news that Game of Thrones surpassed The Sopranos as HBO’s most ‘popular’ show arrived, rather pertinently, via a Tweet. "Raise a glass of...

In Development: The Top 10 Shows You're Going To Want To Look Out For

Since Netflix gained prominence as a fully independent broadcaster in its own right, the doors have been flung open to a hugely varied selection of...

John Oliver Rallies The Internet Trolls To Give The FCC Hell

John Oliver is using his position as satirical-sideways-swiper for good, it would seem. His latest target is the FCC and ‘net neutrality’, and he addressed...

Advertisement

Comments

HBO Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on HBO

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All