Judge Rejects Civil Rights Challenge In Britney Case

by | 27 February 2008

Britney Spears' legal woes will remain in a California court after a judge rejected a civil rights challenge to take the case to a federal court.

Jon Eardley, claiming to represent the Toxic star, had filed a complaint in the US district court on her behalf, alleging that the temporary conservatorship of Britney's estate by her father James was a "violation of civil rights".

He had claimed that the singer retained him as an attorney on February 12th, but Los Angeles superior court commissioner Reva Goetz had ruled two weeks previously that Britney was incapable of hiring her own legal representation.

And now US district judge Philip Gutierrez has sent the case back to California state probate court and rejected the questionable claims of Eardley, a lawyer with practices, in New York; Washington, DC; and Whittier, California.

"Mr Eardley fails to explain why he can bring this claim for her in the first instance. He cannot," Gutierrez wrote in a three-page ruling on Tuesday.

"Mr Eardley had no authority to remove the case from state court. He is neither a party nor a defendant. While he claims to be Ms Spears' attorney, the probate court... found that she was incapable of retaining her own counsel."

The ruling represents a victory for the 26-year-old's father James and an attorney Andrew Wallet, who were named temporary co-conservators of her estate in late January following the pop star's admission to the psychiatric ward of the UCLA medical centre.

The singer has recently enjoyed her first visits in over a month with her two sons after agreeing a revision of a court order with her ex-husband Kevin Federline.

27/02/2008 09:12:06


Tags: Britney Spears - KEVIN FEDERLINE


More Britney Spears

Ed Sheeran Records New Songs With Swift, Admires Spears, Dedicates Song To Cameron

More Ed Sheeran news in what’s been a mind-bogglingly successful 2014! The distinctive singer-songwriter made a number of revelations during a Q&A session at the...

Britney Spears Is A Picture Of Sophistication With Her Neat New Hair Do

Britney Spears has traded in her trademark long blonde curls for a sleek and sophisticated bob cut as she now embarks on a more serious...

Britney Spears Reveals New Lingerie Collection At New York Public Library

As part of the Mercedes-Benz New York Fashion Week for Spring 2015, Britney Spears attended her own collections premiere, entitled 'The Intimate Britney Spears Show'.The...

Newly Single Britney Spears Admits She Would "Possibly" Join Tinder

For anyone part for the online dating world, one day you may just come across one of the world's biggest pop-stars, Britney Spears. The newly...


No-One Is Safe! The Redemptoristine Sisters Of Dublin Accept Their ALS Ice Bucket Challenge Nomination [Video]

Just when we thought the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge couldn't get any better (we honestly thought the swearing toddler topped them all!), an unlikely group...

Britney Spears Confirms Ex-Boyfriend David Lucado Cheated On Her During Las Vegas Show

Late last week news broke that Britney Spears had split from her boyfriend David Lucado after dating for over a year. In case anyone is...

Britney Spears Splits From Boyfriend David Lucado

Pop singer Britney Spears has split from her boyfriend David Lucado. The star made the announcement by posting on Twitter "Ahhhh the single life!". A...

Beyonce To Receive Vanguard Award At The VMAs. But Mostly, YES, She Will Perform!

Umm, Beyonce will be performing at the MTV Video Music Awards... is anyone really , surprised? Bey is everywhere these days. In the wake of...



Britney Spears Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Britney Spears

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All