Peter Jackson - Is The Hobbit - An Unexpected Journey More Style Than Substance?

Subscribe to Peter Jackson alerts

Peter Jackson's reimaging of J.R.R Tolkien's work has seen one of the biggest film franchises in history emerge: The Lord of The Rings. But his decision to stretch another of Tolkien's yarns over a trilogy has been met with a mixed response from the critics.

Many reviewers have pointed to The Hobbit's aesthetics in a bid to propose a positive note to an otherwise negative review. But, given his previous work with LOTR was both thematically and stylistically approved by the press and fans alike, has The Hobbit fallen short of its expectations?

With a 74% rating on film score aggregator site, Rotten Tomatoes, the suggestion is while the film will entertain fans of the genre, and particularly the franchise, it's lacking as an overall package, and probably won't go down as a classic.

"While fans of J.R.R. Tolkien's novels and The Lord of the Rings movies will find plenty to enjoy and marvel over, non-believers may find themselves getting bored and bemused by the unnecessarily drawn-out story," say The Daily Mirror, adopting the popular condemnation of the film's length.

On a similar vein, Sci Fi Magazine say, "If Peter Jackson couldn't tell this slight story in a single film there's no hope the other two in this prequel series will be any less bloated."

And summing up the film with gusto, The New York Post say it, "Piles on enough eye candy and action sequences to please fans, plus more humor than the three "Rings" films - even if it only occasionally achieves the trio's grandeur."

So there you have it: fan of the Tolkien dream worlds? Then dive right in. But if you're taking your kids to watch this, you better pack a travel cushion and/or a steaming thermos of Irish coffee. 



Tags: Peter Jackson

Subscribe to Peter Jackson alerts

More Peter Jackson

Martin Freeman's Bilbo Baggins Meets Tim Canterbury In SNL's 'The Office: Middle Earth'

Martin Freeman's acting career has been just as much an unpredictable a journey as his character Bilbo Baggins' Middle Earth quest in 'The Hobbit' series,...

Orlando Bloom On Spending Christmas With His Estranged Wife & Moving On From Legolas

Miranda Kerr and Orlando Bloom may have split up well over a year ago but that doesn't mean they hold any animosity toward each other....

Benedict Cumberbatch Is Honoured To Be A Part Of 'The Hobbit' Send-Off

Let's not deny it - since 'The Lord of the Rings' came out, it has been almost every film-goer's dream to be a part of...

The Hobbit Brings Peter Jackson's Saga Full Circle

With 'The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies', Peter Jackson has completed a second trilogy of films based on J.R.R. Tolkien's classic novels 'The...


The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies Movie Review

Peter Jackson's expanded take on J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit comes to a conclusion in a battle epic packed with enormous action sequences that oddly distract...

Peter Jackson And Philippa Boyens - The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies Video Interview

'The Hobbit' director Peter Jackson and screenwriter Philippa Boyens discuss the magic behind the trilogy as they prepare to release the final instalment, 'The Battle...

A Week In Movies: Exodus And The Third Hobbit Premiere In London, As M:I 5 Films Across Town, Spectre Is Announced And Star Wars Teases The Internet

Ridley Scott was on hand for the premiere of his new biblical epic Exodus: Gods and Kings in London this week. Also on the red...

Peter Jackson Quashes Rumors of More Middle Earth Movies

Peter Jackson has quashed rumors of further Middle Earth movies, despite Galdalf himself Sir Ian McKellen suggesting the New Zealand director wasn't done with Tolkien's...



Peter Jackson Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Peter Jackson

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All