How has Elementary – The American Sherlock – gone down with critics?

Subscribe to Jonny Lee Miller alerts

Constantly dubbed ‘the American Sherlock,’ the CBS drama based on the British crime-solver, Elementary, premieres tonight (September 27th) at 10pm. So what are the reviews saying?

Well, first, we should say that this isn’t an official reimagining of the quintessentially British crime franchise, Sherlock, rather an unsanctioned drama which plays on the very core of the Sherlock stories, with its name based on the infamous catchphrase: “Elementary my dear Watson”. CBS, have twice before aired a modern-day series based on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's iconic detective, but this comes right in the middle of the show’s on screen renaissance. IGN give America’s answer to Holmes a fairly good, 7.8 review, saying: “Cumberbatch's version still rules, but Elementary delivers a relatively fresh new take on the Sherlock Holmes story.” Not bad. Entertainment weekly were equally impressed, especially with Miller’s performance: “The primary pleasure of Elementary is Jonny Lee Miller's performance as a present-day Sherlock Holmes: a brilliant, jumpy, self-described ''recovering addict'' fresh out of rehab.”

So not quite a remake, but close enough to the original to be closely compared, and early indications suggest it compares well. The lead character’s rehab background sounds like an interesting addition to a tried and tested character, and given the positive reviews so far, it sounds like tuning in at 10pm tonight won’t be a total waste of time. If you watch the show, tell us what you think below.


Tags: Jonny Lee Miller

Subscribe to Jonny Lee Miller alerts

More Jonny Lee Miller

First Glimpse Of Lucy Liu And Jonny Lee Miller In Second Series Of 'Elementary'

'Lucky Number Slevin' star Luvy Liu and 'Eli Stone' star Jonny Lee Miller are snapped filming a scene on the set of their modern Sherlock...

'Elementary' My Dear... Mycroft? Rhys Ifans To Join The Cast Of Sherlock Holmes

Rhys Ifans will join the cast of Elementary, alongside Jonny Lee Miller and Lucy Lui. The Welsh actor will play Mycroft Holmes, Sherlock's older brother....

Byzantium Movie Review

Nearly 20 years after Interview With the Vampire, Neil Jordan returns to the genre to breath some new life into a mythology that has grown...

Sharon Osbourne And The Cast Of 'How I Met Your Mother' Among CBS Upfront 2013 Star Arrivals - Part 4

Among the CBS TV show actors arriving at the network's 2013 Upfront Presentation in New York were Sharon Osbourne from 'The Talk' (who doesn't refrain...


Byzantium Trailer

Clara and Eleanor are a mother and daughter, born two centuries ago as vampires and surviving only on the blood of mortal beings. They escape...

Elementary Is Highest Rated Broadcast Of 2013 (With A Little Help From Super Bowl)

Despite being the latest ever start time for a post-Super Bowl broadcast, Sherlock Holmes drama Elementary scored a massive 20.8 million viewers on Sunday evening...

Jonny Lee Miller Of Elementary Had 'No Idea' How Entertaining Sherlock Was

The star of the latest Sherlock Holmes reincarnation, Jonny Lee Miller, who plays the mercurial crime solver in Elementary, has admitted he had no idea...

Johnny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu in Elementary Premiers in the UK

American Sherlock Holmes adaptation 'Elementary' is now in its second season in America, but premièred last night on Sky Living in the UK. Film and...



Jonny Lee Miller Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Jonny Lee Miller

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All