American Idol Judges Turn On Haley Reinhart In Semi Final - Comments and Message Board

Comments Return to Article

Lady Robyn's picture

Lady Robyn

To tylerstwit: Get off of Steven's nuts. To Steven: I respect you. I've seen you in concert... but do us a favor: Stay out of MJ territory. Thank you.
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490065

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

Lorraine Anne Longshaw-Harrietha's picture

Lorraine Anne L...

Tyler is brain dead from all those drugs!
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322519110

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

corlista's picture

corlista

"Not a hit song." ?? Steven Tyler is clueless.
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490050

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

Grandma Chicken's picture

Grandma Chicken

Haley is not the favorite to get the boot after last night's performance. Where was the writer of this article during the rest of the show. Do you not remember hearing JLo telling the audience that the second song Haley sang was the best performance of the year?About the Michael Jackson song: Did you not hear Steven Tyler tell Haley to ignore what the judges were saying? Lady GaGa said about Haley that she was "perfect" and that she only needed to add more "drama" to her performance.Haley is the only one in there I would pay to see in a concert. She is hugely talented, entertaining, knowledgeable about music, and would not bore me. I am a 64-year-old grandma ... I have heard and seen "amazing" in my time!
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490050

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

Great Balls of Fire's picture

Great Balls of Fire

The judges on American Idol clearly don't like Haley nor do they want to see her make it to the final three. Very sad. It's ok for James Durbin to sing off key and pitchy. It's ok for Scotty McCreery to bore us to death with an Alan Jackson song, then run around like a loon on stage making faces and holding the mike sideways. It's ok for 16 year old Lauren Alaina to sing about being an evil woman. She is too young to be taken seriously singing that song. Yet, they were all praised for jobs well done. Come on judges, get real and stop your bias. Haley is the most talented singer with the greatest range and capacity for true stardom, while James, Scotty and Lauren are one-trick ponies.
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490051

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

Carol Sue Jimerson's picture

Carol Sue Jimerson

To Lorraine: NO YOU are brain dead! Tyler gave up the drugs. Did YOU?
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490051

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

Carol Sue Jimerson's picture

Carol Sue Jimerson

To Corlista: Tyler has more music knowledge than you could ever dream of having.
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490051

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments

360colors's picture

360colors

Steven Tyler said more than just, "It wasn't a hit song." He actually strongly suggested that judges, Randy and J-Lo, were off the mark and that Haley shouldn't listen to them. Sorry, but your reporting is off the mark.
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490052

3 years 2 months ago
Report
View Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement