American Idol Final 2 Confirmed As Reinhart Goes Home - Comments and Message Board

Comments Return to Article

Robert LeClair's picture

Robert LeClair

There ain't no way Haley wasen't the best. She could sing it all and looked so good on stage. That Opie Taylor looking Scotty is a one trick pony and he ain't that great. I think it was a popularity contest not a talent contest. Steven Taylor knew who was best and that was Haley by far !!
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322519134

3 years 4 months ago
Report
View Comments

maizie's picture

maizie

What a lot of rubbish - Haley mucked up because she fell???? She picked herself up so quickly and carried on like a real trooper. Such a boring finish with Scotty, and Lauren - who never ever hit her high notes........... Should be renamed Country & Western American Idol. It was so noticable with Jennifer Lopez, her lack of enthusiasm for Haley, even although she sang her little sox off - she was miles ahead of Lauren............... Maybe Jenny from the block saw a little diva in the making and it made her a*s twitch - couldn't take the competition of a talented vibrant 20 year old. I think Haley will fare better than any of the two finalists, good luck to you girl. Not watching the final, but hope it is Scotty that wins. Such a boring end Y A W N..............
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490077

3 years 4 months ago
Report
View Comments

maizie's picture

maizie

What a lot of rubbish - Haley mucked up because she fell???? She picked herself up so quickly and carried on like a real trooper. Such a boring finish with Scotty, and Lauren - who never ever hit her high notes........... Should What a lot of rubbish - Haley mucked up because she fell???? She picked herself up so quickly and carried on like a real trooper. Such a boring finish with Scotty, and Lauren - who never ever hit her high notes........... Should be renamed Country & Western American Idol. It was so noticable with Jennifer Lopez, her lack of enthusiasm for Haley, even although she sang her little sox off - she was miles ahead of Lauren............... Maybe Jenny from the block saw a little diva in the making and it made her a*s twitch - couldn't take the competition of a talented vibrant 20 year old. I think Haley will fare better than any of the two finalists, good luck to you girl. Not watching the final, but hope it is Scotty that wins. Such a boring end Y A W N..............
Import Source: 
comments.nsf
Import Date: 
1322490077

3 years 4 months ago
Report
View Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement