Cowell Blasts American Idol Winners

SIMON COWELL reportedly launched a blistering attack on past AMERICAN IDOL winners during a heated phone call with the reality TV show's executive producer CECILE FROT-COUTAZ.

The BMG RECORDS boss was overheard complaining that 2003 winner RUBEN STUDDARD and 2004 victor FANTASIA BARRINO were undeserving of their recording contracts, and warned Frot-Coutaz that this year's (05) contest will again be full of untalented wannabes.

An eavesdropper at Los Angeles' L'Ermitage Hotel tells gossip website PAGESIX.COM, "He said that there is very little talent in the pool of contestants that made it to the finals in Los Angeles.

"(Apart from a Missouri country and western singer) he said the rest were just a bunch of 'untalented USHER wannabes' and predicted the show would end up again with 'someone like Ruben or Fantasia' winning.

"He said KELLY CLARKSON (2002 winner) was the only one with talent who ever won."

04/02/2005 09:42


Tags: Simon Cowell - American Idol - Fantasia Barrino - Usher - Kelly Clarkson


More Simon Cowell

Simon Cowell Claims US X Factor "Will Come Back Again" Despite Cancelation

Simon Cowell is undoubtedly a huge success and has transformed the music industry forever, but despite having a near-flawless career in several television and music...

Simon Cowell Reckons One Direction's Success Won't Be Repeated

As Britain’s premier pop music mogul, Simon Cowell isn’t one to mince his words. Ahead of the first live shows of the current eleventh series...

Despite Cowell's Return, 'Strictly' Topples X-Factor in Sunday Ratings

It is a battle that could have perhaps been avoided had either the BBC or ITV backed down and rescheduled, but Strictly Come Dancing and...

Leona Lewis Writes Open Letter To Fans Discussing Reasons Behind Her Exit From Simon Cowell’s Syco Label

Leona Lewis has posted a handwritten, open letter to her fans on Twitter, discussing her feelings of depression and the reasons behind her departure...


GRL Members and Simon Cowell Lead Tributes To Singer Simone Battle

Simone Battle’s G.RL. bandmates have paid tribute to the singer, writing that they will "carry her memory with us in everything we do,” on the...

Simon Cowell Reveals He Wants More Children With Girlfriend Lauren Silverman

Even though Simon Cowell only became a father six months ago, the music mogul has enjoyed parenthood so much he recently admitted to wanting to...

X Factor Judges Star In £1million 'Game Of Thrones Promo'

The latest series of the X Factor looks set to be the most epic one yet - if the first promo is anything to go...

Cheryl Cole Doesn't Hold A Grudge Against Simon Cowell Or Ashley Cole

In a recent interview with Elle, Cheryl Cole discussed her relationship with Simon Cowell, her sacking from The X Factor US in 2011 and her...



Jenifer's picture


We absolutely adore Simon Cowell, he is the only t judgepers on on American Idol who does not patronize the competitors, he is up front so it will bring out the best in each person performing, one cannot improve without contructive critisim, which Simon does, besides enoying the entertainment, we are always guaranteed a good laugh anticipating Simon's remarks, would not watch this program without him on it with his remarks, he is so honest and funny without trying.
Import Source: 
Import Date: 

6 years 8 months ago
View Comments

Simon Cowell Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Simon Cowell

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All