Comment on this review

Neil Young - Living With War Album Review


Neil Young -  Living With War - Album Review
Neil Young Glastonbury Festival picture 2477663 Neil Young Glastonbury Festival picture 2477659
Click for the Neil Young Gallery

Artist - Neil Young
Album - Living With War
Label - Reprise


Stepping, with lumberjack boots, into the whole Iraq war debate, Living With War leaves the listener in no doubt whatsoever about Young's position.

Whether it is a great Neil Young album, however, is more debatable. With a grunge-core sound reminiscent of Zuma, and lyrics that are among his best ever (whether you agree with his viewpoint or not), he has clearly channelled a whole lot of aggression into this piece. However, it doesn't sound great - it's all a bit tame and rote.

The sense is of an album that would undoubtedly work well live, but it all seems a bit rushed. The best track is the first - After The Garden. While protest albums make sense here and now, there isn't a lot that will make Living With War a staple of a Best Of in the future.

Rating 7/10

Mike Rea

click here - Write for us - get your reviews published on Contactmusic


Click Here for all you need to know about: Neil Young







Comment on this review


Comments

screen name:

musicdelite Click for more info (2)

posted on 24/06/2006 19:54


comments:

Living With War He felt it, he wrote it, he sang it..Well done Neil!!




screen name:

wayside Click for more info ( 1)

posted on 20/05/2006 19:26


comments:

Living with War is brilliant. Neil Young has lost none of his biting edge and his sentiments echo 'Ohio' all those years ago. But, regardless of your view of his lyrics, this is also a good rock album (apart from the last track!)






©2009 Contactmusic.com Ltd, all rights reserved