Comment on this review

Bob Dylan - Various Artists, I'm Not There: Original Soundtrack Album Review


Various Artists - I'm Not There: Original Soundtrack Album Review
Bob Dylan picture 5171271 Bob Dylan picture 5171277
Click for the Bob Dylan Gallery

Various Artists
I'm Not There: Original Soundtrack
Album Review


Bob Dylan has always been covered - The Byrds, Jimi Hendrix, for example - and this soundtrack to the Dylan biopic sees him being covered afresh by a wide variety of artists. Eddie Vedder, Sonic Youth, Cat Power, Iron & Wine, Yo La Tengo, Jeff Tweedy, The Hold Steady, The Black Keys and Sufjan Stevens, among others, show just how relevant Dylan's music is to an indie audience. Holding the fort for the older stagers are artists like Roger McGuinn, Tom Verlaine and Ramblin' Jack Elliot. You could always head to iTunes and only download tracks by your favourites (and in so doing avoid the truly awful Antony and the Johnsons, and the mere fillers, such as Mira Billotte's I Went Out One Morning), but the sweep of this double CD is fantastic.

The best Dylan songs allow a whole lot of interpretation, and the most successful tracks here sound like the artists' own. Yo La Tengo's I Wanna Be Your Lover is excellent, as is Sufjan Stevens' Ring Them Bells. Calexico provide backing for many of the artists, as do the assembled band the Million Dollar Bashers (which includes Tom Verlaine), which tends to move them all towards a similar sound. In the end, unless your favourite band is here, or you're the kind of Dylan fan who needs to have the new Dylan title track, there's not much for you - buy by the track.

Rating 7/10

Mike Rea

click here - Write for us - get your reviews published on Contactmusic


Click Here for all you need to know about: Bob Dylan








Official Site - http://www.bobdylan.com


Comment on this review


Comments

screen name:

rola Click for more info ( 1)

posted on 17/11/2007 11:04


comments:

Antony is a genius and his music touches peoples' hearts in a such a powerful fashion that it doesn't matter what so called "critics" have to say. While his voice and music will last for aeons, the ephemeral reviews will be rightly long gone forgotten... Antony and the Johnson's cover is one of the most wonderful piece of music i ever heard. rola




screen name:

nicocin Click for more info ( 1)

posted on 16/11/2007 17:25


comments:

Well I think that Antony's "Knockin' On Heaven's Door" is the best track on the CD and that your review is AWFUL! Actually I am glad that the CD is available on iTunes - at least it affords me the opportunity to purchase only Antony's track.






©2009 Contactmusic.com Ltd, all rights reserved