My Winnipeg Movie Review
My Winnipeg Review

"My Winnipeg" Overview

Rating: NR
2008
Cast and Crew
Director : Guy MaddinProducer : Jody Shapiro,Phyllis Laing
Screenwiter : Guy Maddin
Starring : Darcy Fehr,Ann Savage,Amy Stewart,Louis Negin,Brandan Cade,Wesley Cade,Kate Yacula
My Winnipeg, the latest walk down memory lane from Canadian maestro Guy Maddin, flirts most
flagrantly with commercial appeal and convention. This goes double for a filmmaker
who has consistently burrowed himself into the fractured nostalgia of the silent
era, peep shows, news reels, and ham-fisted/hard-boiled noirs with nothing but wild-blue-yonder
glee. Yet, besides its outset of being a "documentary," there is little familiar
about Maddin's wonderscape that isn't hardwired directly into the auteur's stylistic
stigmas.
It all starts, as it so often does, on a train. The main character (Darcy Fehr),
a rebellious, alternate-reality incarnation of Maddin himself, sleeps and dreams
his way through the main avenues, alleyways and inlets of Winnipeg in the business
class section of a ghost engine. Desperate to leave the memories of his home burg, he
begins remembering his childhood, partly recreates it, and then peppers it with large
swigs of fantasized recollections and recreational mythologies.
The Maddin aesthetic has always drifted from honest nostalgia to corrupted apparitions
to full-blown fantasia but he has always been, at heart, a storyteller. With Win
nipeg, the landscape fractures early: It opens with Maddin directing noir legend Ann Savage
as she prepares to play his mother, scolding his older sister for an illicit affair
she's had. What follows is a carnivalesque exhibition of destroyed totems of Maddin's you
th and an awfully funny rendering of his home life as the runt of the litter, not
much bigger than the pug he casts as his fondly-remembered puppy.
My Winnipeg instills memory as ice-laden spectre: insular, amorphous, and mystic in its reverie.
Reality and hallucinated reminiscence blur at the edges: Who would believe that If
Day, a yearly supposition of what would have happened if the Nazis had taken Manitoba, is
completely legit, but what about baby Guy's birth in the locker room of homegrown
hockey titans the Winnipeg Maroons? The remnants of a race track fire that burned
a dozen or so horses alive allows for some of Maddin's most haunted (haunting?) imagery
. Sticking out of the tundra as if frozen as they emerged from hell, the glacial
horse heads, stuck in contortions of anguish, have become a tourist attraction, a
photo op spectacle and, most disturbingly, a hang-out for teens. Each perverse locale
he visits yields to the sublimity of Maddin's film.
What Maddin has done here is quite miraculous. Engulfing his pristine black-and-white
photography in a snowy haze, lost in a wonderland of his own making, Maddin turns
his birthplace into a mythic brume where one's feet are strictly forbidden from the
ground. If everyone paints their hometown as a veritably unknown world of demons, saints,
perverts, monuments, and "the best diner ever," Maddin goes inward and turns his
hometown into his own personalized whirligig. It's a place where Ledge Man repeats are
waiting for you when you get home and Citizen Girl waits to remedy even the slightest
sense of injustice. And they say you can't go home again.
Let's play hockey.
Reviewer: Chris Cabin



