View all comments (1) - Comment on this review
August Rush Movie Review
August Rush Review

"August Rush" Overview

Rating: PG
2007
Cast and Crew
Director : Kirsten SheridanProducer : Richard Barton Lewis
Screenwiter : Nick Castle,James V. Hart
Starring : Freddie Highmore,Keri Russell,Jonathan Rhys Meyers,Robin Williams,Terrence Howard
Going in to August Rush, you've got to be more than willing to accept fairy
tale magic; you've got to be looking to embrace it, with all of its whimsy and
overzealous sense of wonder. That way, the movie can be sweet (if a bit
ponderously so) as opposed to so precious you feel the need to punt it through
a window. It's a fine line, and August Rush is balancing it the whole way
through.
Freddie Highmore plays the title character, a little boy in a Dickensian
version of the real world: He has grown up in a group home for boys in upstate
New York (do they even have those anymore?), where he hears music in the world,
from the corn fields to the moonlight. He sets out one day, believing that if
he follows the music, it will lead to his parents; where it actually leads is
New York City, where the noise of the city turns into the rhythmic beginnings
of a Stomp number. There, he hooks up with a band of street urchins/musicians
straight out of Oliver Twist, run by the unstable and off-putting Wizard (Robin
Williams as a creepy redhead). When August discovers things like guitars and
sheet music that allow him to produce the music he hears, he becomes a prodigy,
and a sensation.
And of course, because August Rush is all about the magic of fate and
coincidence, this little boy's love of music comes from some sort of
machinations of the gods: His mother Lyla (Keri Russell) is a star concert
cellist; his father Louis (Jonathan Rhys Meyers) is the guitarist and singer of
a rock band. The two meet by coincidence on a rooftop and share one perfect
night of moonlight and music, and are separated after. As August is looking for
them, they are looking for one another and him. It's a small world, really,
that separates August from his parents, but despite the number of coincidences
and close calls that have parents and child nearly meeting, it takes them a
very, very long time to actually get there.
If you find a story so heavy on the charm appealing, though, then August Rush
delivers. Highmore is a spectacularly endearing little boy, and he plays the
wise-beyond-his-years waif to perfection. Besides that, the film is cast almost
entirely with likable and recognizable stars; in addition to Russell, Meyers,
and Williams, Terrence Howard plays a sympathetic employee of child protective
services, and even the tiny supporting parts are filled by actors from TV shows
like Ugly Betty and Moonlight. If nothing else, August Rush is pleasant, so
long as you don't go looking for realism or practicality.
Director Kirsten Sheridan is too fond of close-up camera shots and long, silent
takes to make a movie that moves at a rapid clip, however. And while it is
impressive that all three stars are actually performing some of their onscreen
music, for a movie that is all about a dazzling musical prodigy, the actual
music is good, but not astounding. While it is totally in character for a fairy
tale to feature people who feel an instant and inexplicable connection to one
another, August Rush relies on the device more than is strictly necessary, and
unfortunately is content to have it stand in for actual character development.
The movie is every bit as super sweet and precious as it sounds; it's also
rather slow, and prone to long sequences of nothing but light playing off shiny
objects and cacophonies of rhythmic sound. It also places its entire plot on
the belief that a mother can instantly recognize a son she's never seen, that
fate wields an actively guiding hand, and that music can transcend all other
forms of communication in ways that we inherently understand, if we merely
listen. Even if it sounds like so much touchy-feely nonsense, August Rush
manages it with just enough sincerity and embracing of magic that it manages to
stay just this side of saccharine, most of the time.
I'll never cut my hair again!
|
Review by Anne Gilbert
|
Have you seen the movie that I did? It could have been so much better. I saw
subtexting from actors and the beginning of character development that should
have been foundations instead of finished screen products.
The seduction scene..........felt it was forced. Why did she take his hand? I
didn't feel that there was enough motiviation for that. The kiss was a typical
Hollywood kiss but I felt there was not enough action to precede the kiss as to
where it would have made sense.
The first music writing scene...........Where did he learn to make the
sixteenth notes and put the stems in the right place. The information from his
friend was just basic notes and not even any other notes other than whole
notes. He learned all of the other material at Julliard. I understand prodigy
and I was okay with that but the music writing did not work for me
The last scene...............She has not seen him for eleven years and counting
and she looked at him as if she had just left a dinner date with him and they
went to the park. Where was the realism in their meeting after a decade?
There was nothing on their face to make me believe that they had been apart for
more than five minutes. She hadn't ever seen her son and I watched her eyes
and facial expression and it didn't register this was the first time she had
ever seen him. I can buy the listening through the wires and the sensing of
each other's presence but it didn't flow for me.
The dad's confession.................It looked like he was in the bed and read
lines. What was wrong with him, what was his malady, never saw it or felt it.
Understood Meyers angst for a performing musician but never really understood
why Lyla was so torn. There wasn't enough for me to feel sorry for her or
connect to her as a musician controlled by dad.
Could have been a real tear jerker along the lines of the Champ. They really
missed the essence of what they could have had and it could have been a
classic.
View all comments (1) - Comment on this review







