Noel Gallagher Attacks X Factor And Dannii Minogue Message Board and Comments

well i am actually a HUGE fan of the Minogue sisters especially Dannii, and as for that comment about cheryl and Dannii having 'basic voices' and they 'sound exactly the same' i have to completely disagree with you. dannii has the most unique voice i have ever heard( and as well as Kylie's) and cheryl-well im not interested in her so i dont really care. but come on give Dannii a break-her sister had breast cancer and so did her best friend, and you coulnt even imagine how hard that could of been for her. And for the other comments like 'can any one even remember any of her songs' WELL I CERTAINLY CAN I CAN NAME ALMOST ALL OF THEM-THANK YOU VERY MUCH!!!!!!!!!! and Dannii DOES deserve to be a pop star and whether people like it or not SHE IS POPULAR AND ALWAYS WILL BE

Noel Gallagher is "spot on" , i get sick and tired of hearing from some of these contestants on x factor saying "i always wanted to be a star" and parents saying similar. what a load of garbage. they want to serve an appreticeship and spend a few years singing in the pubs etc, get in some of the pubs in any area with live music and you will see "real performers" doing it for the love of it, and not instant fame. and as for that smug git simon cowell! all he cares about is the money that he makes from this trash, "churn em in-churn em out" is his motto, he,s not interested in long term careers, as for "danni minogue" can anybody name any of her hits ?? if so "will they be remembered in say 10 years time " i doubt it" so good on yer Noel, lets get back to some real musical talent

Noel has every right to critise the X Factor. I agree with him 100%. Having hit singles isn't about talent, it's about little boys and girls getting their parents to buy them music which has a short shelve life. Oasis are one of the best Rock and Roll bands to come from Britain. They NOW how to write their own songs rather then getting someone else to write them! Danii and Cherly only have moderate singing voices, they sound exactly the same.

I totally agree with Noel Gallagher, yes he may have a big mouth but in this instance is correct. The judges have less talent than those that have been sent home. This is all about television ratings & Simon Cowells bank balance,its about time all of you sheep that follow this crap, start turning your tv's off.

wat right has noel gallagher got 2 say dannii minouge got no talent when did he and oasis last av a hit single oasis is talentless do us all favour noel leave england and take ur brother with u