Idol Star Aiken Caught Up In Church Gay Controversy Message Board and Comments

and so it continues. Just because a liar explains his words as "sarcastic recant" means he is to be believed? He has lied from day one. He does not care whom he hurts or how. His main goal is to aggravate fans to the point of lying about who they are, posting their names and numbers on a blog and calling them. Is this being done by others? perhaps..but the issue is what is being done by THIS particular man..who professes a belief in God and an allegance to his country. God can't be proud of everyone he brings into this world can he?

OMG....is John Paulus still trying to push his fan fiction!!!! This jerk, Paulus is so over the top with the crap he spews. Clay Aiken wasn't in Raleigh, NC the day he claims the "hook up" happened. It never happened...Paulus has never met Clay Aiken. Yes, John Paulus recanted his story when he feared he would be asked to testify in a court case. That incident passed so he recanted his recant. Paulus is stupid but apparently not stupid enough to lie on a witness stand. He is a self-serving famewhore who wants another 15 minutes.

Gee, JP! Remember very early into this smear campaign when you were asked the time of the tryst? You replied 5:33 (who gives time down to the exact minute?) but when people told you that was impossible because he was in NYC in meetings you later changed your story to something like 8:30. Still wrong; still impossible. During some of these same conversations on your blog you said Clay arrived in his new car which was later changed to a rental from the airport which was changed back to his new car. You could see his eyes through the window? Duhhhhh... it's dark at 5:30 in winter. Still doesn't top when you were trying to be so convincing on PH's and BM's blog before you sold your story to NE. He said Clay was 5'8" and when JP walked through the hallway with him Clay hid behind him so the maintenance man wouldn't see him. How does a guy 5'6" in platforms (more like 5'4") hide a man 9 inches taller than he? By all means, visit the blogs listed above, Mr. AntiMusic, because it would really be nice if someone other than the fans would tell the darned truth for once and not humor this deranged, delusional stalker. Repeating his stories and the tabloid stories he provides for them validates his thinking that he is untouchable. He's dangerous and that's the truth.

First of all, the church did not say that Clay wasn't welcome. Visit their website and you will see a totally different picture. They are delighted that he is holding a concert in their church. This whole story is coming from one person who is a Clay stalker and attention seeker that keeps contacting the National Enquirer in hopes of getting his picture in the paper and hoping for a career in porn. Unfortunately sometimes it works because the NE isn't smart enough to know what he's after and they like to publish sordid stories regardless of whether they are true or not or what kind of depraved person they are coming from. You need to visit some other blogs that tell the real story of the stalker. You can start with Chexxxy's Pearls and LiesBiteBack. There are also many links to other blogs that will enlighten you.

This guy is a liar of top caliber. The National Enquirer isn't any better, encouraging his lies. See John Paulus' recant in his own words. http://chexxyspearls.blogspot.com/2007/10/john-paulus-says-it-was-all-hoax.html# links

This guy is a liar of top caliber. The National Enquirer isn't much better. See his recant in his own words. http://chexxyspearls.blogspot.com/2007/10/john-paulus-says-it-was-all-hoax.html# links

Here's an article that says that John Paulus lied. http://www.postchronicle.com/cgi-bin/artman/exec/view.cgi?archive=10&num=67708 So John Paulus is a liar? Shocking! A little over a year ago the Post Chronicle published a series of articles defending the claims against American Idol runnerup Clay Aiken by Paulus and received a great deal of grief. The Clay Aiken haters seemed determined to make the story John Paulus concocted true regardless of its validity. We also published an exclusive interview with Paulus which you can read below. After telling the National Enquirer about his alleged 90 minute bareback sex session with Clay Aiken and then posting photos of the alleged clean-up towel on his blog, John Paulus is now all of a sudden sorry about the whole story. In a long-winded apology on his blog, Paulus claims to have had a come to Jesus meeting. He's apparently seen the light about his actions and not recently, but immediately after selling the dirt to the Enquirer, and his blog was never a tool to hurt Clay's career, but rather to fight back against his fans. Like our friends at Queerty, "We wonder if his feelings of contrition got in the way of his performance in the porno he shot for Michael Lucas." The Blog entry has since been removed but the Neutral Zone has the text. So now we find out that like many, we were right all along. A Hat tip goes out to Mike Baron and Jim Brogan for their contributions to this subject. ----------------------------------------------------- Here's JP's confession taken directly from his blog: John Paulus Says… “It Was All A Hoax” March 2, 2007 Posted by Twilight Dreamer in John Paulus, National Enquirer, Neutral Zone, Lucas Entertainment, Michael Lucas, Clay Aiken, Tabloids, Gay, Celebrity, American Idol, Public Figures, music. trackback In an unexpected turn of events, former Green Beret, John Paulus, said on his weblog earlier this morning that he lied about his alleged January 2, 2006 sexual tryst with Clay Aiken. This comes after more than a year of passionate assertion, whereby Paulus was adamant that he had a sexual encounter with Aiken in a North Carolina hotel room. Paulus previously claimed Aiken engaged him in conversation on the “Big Muscle” gay website, and they subsequently met for sex. According to Paulus, he later felt rejected by Aiken after his attempts to contact Aiken were snubbed. Consequently, Paulus talked to the tabloids and press alleging that he was in possession of a towel containing DNA evidence, IM chat transcripts, and incriminating nude webcam shots of Aiken. Paulus passed two lie detector tests for the National Enquirer, his initial contact. As of March 2, 2007, John Paulus is singing a different tune. According to Paulus, he was recruited by a group of eight people in July of 2005 to carry out a plot to discredit Aiken’s straight-arrow image and portray him as a promiscuous homosexual. Paulus is claiming they located him from the “Big Muscle” gay website… “They saw me there and that I was muscular, attractive, and from NC. and persuaded me to help them. So we worked out this scheme over 6 months and put it into place going over ever detail. I even took 3 prior lie detector test so that I could pass one by any media that gave me one.” According to Paulus, “… it was nothing but a story concocted by another Idols fans and I was nothing, but the front person in this scheme.” What about the evidence previously offered up by Paulus? Said Paulus, “Oh what about the cumrag? Used a prop. And the cell phone calls? They were calls made by “haters” to my phone. And the hotel room? There was really a room 207 and I really did check in and I did walk with someone into the room.” “Clay and I never met nor have we ever had sex.” All of this begs the question, why would John Paulus participate in such a scheme and then cling to it so tenaciously for more than a year? Paulus explained, “My only compensation was that they would get me in touch with Lucas to do porno.” In his estimation, Paulus’ porn flick, for Lucas Entertainment, New York City, paid his bills for an entire year. After Paulus initially went public with his allegations, last year, he claimed that some of Aikens’ fans (also known as Claymates) sent threatening emails and death threats, telephoned him at his job, and got him fired from his job, prompting him to contact the FBI for protection. An added incentive for Paulus to stick with his story, after his Lucas Entertainment deal, was… “Because Claymates pissed me off and it was fun messing with them.” He got his porn deal, he messed with the Claymates; so what caused John Paulus to do this sudden about face and claim that his liaison with Aiken was all part of a grand scheme in which he played only a small role? When asked, Paulus explained that his co-conspirators were offended by his apparently softening stance on Aiken, and he felt they were attempting to discredit him…. “Because when I told the haters I was over this and didn’t want to be a part of their game and I defended Clay by saying he looked good and happy on Kimmel they attacked me and said I was a traitor. I can not go on lying for them and destroying a good person.” Amongst those, who Paulus alleged were involved, included an accused blog owner who goes by the name of “Percocet” and owns the “Clay Aiken Fraud Squad” blog, formerly named, “Rabid Claymates Exposed”. Percocet denied that she had any involvement in, or knowledge of, the “scheme” that Paulus spoke of. “I am not, and to the best of my knowledge, noone on my blog is in any kind of cooperation with JP. It is becoming clear how insane he is. You can read his e-mails that he sent to me earlier tonight in my blog comments at 411. JP is just concocting a big story.” Paulus went on to say, “I’d be willing to have a press conference admitting that this was all a lie and that Clay and I never met nor did he ever solicit me for sex and that as far as I know he is straight.” In a conciliatory tone, Paulus added, “I hope that the Claymates will forgive me as Clay has.” But like sands through the hourglass, no soap opera is ever over. Paulus has more to reveal, “I will share more about this scheme put together by posters on the 411 over the weekend” -------------------------------------------------------------- John Paulus is not only a liar, he is evil, dangerous and a stalker. We don't need to do a thing to you John. You will pay, you will be so sorry for everything you've done. Why do you continue to stalk Clay? Why are you so obsessed by him that you want to ruin his life? I think you need to have an order to stay away from him and to never write any lies about him ever again. I hope Clay will sue you for everything you have done to him. You are nothing but a laughingstock to Percocet and that 411 lot. They have just used the hell out of you!

Maybe Paulus will do the same as Tom Cruise's lying fame whore stalker did. He just recently committed suicide. Go for it Johnny!

Maybe Paulus will do the same as Tom Cruise's lying fame whore stalker did. He just recently committed suicide. Go for it Johnny!

Paulus is a wannabe porn star, hoping to cash in on his imaginary tryst with Clay Aiken. He's been trying for TWO YEARS! It's time to give it up, fame-whore! Nobody believes you anymore. You've adjusted your fabricated story toooooo many times. Plus those of us who know and adore Clay KNOW what kind of a fine, straight young man he is. He wouldn't go near the likes of you. Clay is going to be an honored performer at the upcoming Neil Sedaka Tribute in New York, singing Neil's song, "Solitaire". Those of you who have never seen or heard Clay, do yourself a favor and get a preview here: http://youtube.com/watch?v=xesnCf1R7_4

Hate to disappoint you, but Paulus did indeed recant. Of course since some media people want the attention that only sensational and scandalous headlines, and some in the industry are actively involved in a smear campaign to ruin both Aiken's career and personal life, they undoubtably didn't tell you that. I have had the opportunity to witness Aiken on TV or in concert numerous times. The man is quite straight, very much a faith-filled believer, and has lied on neither issue. The pastor spoke truth when he said that Aiken is straight and Paulus recanted his heavily-fabricated story (which did have numerous holes punched in it early on, before he began changing it up).

Clay Aiken will never acknowledge acusations made by a psychotic stalker. As any psychologist will confirm, as has Dr. Phil, getting recognition from the victim only feeds the stalker. Clay's family, friends, fans, and all those meaningful to him know that he is NOT gay, others believe what they want, so he's not going to continue discussing his private life. Saying he has never had a girlfriend is ludicrous, and illustrates how little this stalker, John Paulus knows about Clay. There is no scandal at the church where Clay will be performing, but the stalker sent fabricated salacious materials about Clay to the pastor there to create one, and have his name mentioned in a trashy tabloid where he has contacts that condone and publish his lies to sell to guillible readers.

The fairy tales perpetrated by John Paulass, an internet stalker of Clay Aiken, have been recanted,as posted on many internet sites. Then the stalker recanted his recant. Recently he recanted part of his recanted recant. He has been caught in lie after lie, only to create more lies to cover his most recent lies. This is an unstable, worthless pile of refuse who is insanely jealous of Clay. To believe him is to be a dimwit.

IS that stalker dude still at it? Seems to me he protests too much, unlike Mr. Aiken, who lives his life with quiet dignity.

Claymates would like to believe that their 28 year old crooner, who's never had a girlfriend, is straight, but I can assure you from personal experience that he is gay. Clay fans make being gay out to be some crime. It's no big deal.

Is this stalker creep STILL trying to get attention out of this worn out fiction? What a famewhore. . . . . It never happened. . . . . Get over it.

Is this stalker creep STILL trying to get attention out of this worn out fiction? What a famewhore. It never happened. Get over it.

It's unfortunate that John Paulus thinks his recant was just a minor retort to something that Clayfans said. He was arguing with a non-fan when he began his recant. It was posted for a day before he decided to recant his recant. Sarcasm it was not. You can see for yourself as the screencaps show it all. http://chexxyspearls.blogspot.com/

It's unfortunate that in their desperation, Clay fans would take a sarcastic retort that I made in response to their ludicrous assertion and construe it as a statement of fact. Again, there was never a legitimate recant made by me nor will there be. I stand by the story I told to the National Enquirer and to Howard Stern.

Clay Aiken had an opportunity to address the claims I made back in 2006, but declined. Instead his management and publicist both declined comment when asked by several media sources if the allegations were true. In interviews back in September 2006 with Diane Sawyer, and Larry King, when asked whether or not he was gay, Clay declined an opportunity to provide a yes or no answer. In an interview in 2006 by 'People Magazine' he was again asked the question and again he chose to equivocate rather than answers the reporter with a yes or no. His current refusal and equivocation to the question provide credibility to my assertions. Those using his 2003 Rolling Stones interview as evidence of his heterosexuality do so in desperation to support their own illusions.

The recant happened and the screencaps can be found here: http://chexxyspearls.blogspot.com/

This is a shame that this has happened because Clay has said before that he is not gay...namely in the Rolling Stone Magazine article from 2003. What a shame that a lie from someone who makes untrue claims about Clay has to cause such decent person so much trouble. As for JP saying that he never took back what he said about Clay, he once again is lieing. He said it and "seemed" to have a change of heart about doing it. He actually seemed sorry, so you would think. He seems to be an up and down person. Sorry one minute and then taking it all back the next. I wish he'd just go away for good.

Yeah...you are JP. JP had enough Claymate hate mail. He would not beg for more.

Paulus did, in fact, refute his story after Clay divulged he was under tremendous stress and was on medication. Clay has stated repeatedly that he is not gay. He should tell that hypocritical church to pray for themselves and question Jesus's sexuality. After all, he was in his 30s, supposedly unmarried in a time when that was viewed as dangerous, and was presumably childless--nother no-no during that era. So if they want to pray to an unmarried, childless Jew and not question his sexuality, they ought to respect the words of a talented, honest, charitable, honorable young man who has been untouched by scandal except through the unproven allegations of others. Good grief! Have you seen him tapping his foot in an airport bathroom stall? Has anyone witnessed this so-called lie-detector test? Has he been holding hands with Boy George? And so what if he was gay? Does that make him less talented? Less generous? Less of a human being created by god? NO! Get over it!!!

I am John Paulus and I have not recanted my claims. I made a sarcastic comment in reply to a Clay Aiken fan that was taken literally. I stand by the story as reported by the National Enquirer and as told by me on the Howard Stern Show. Anyone wishing to authentic can contact me at JohnPaulus@gmail.com

John Paulus Says… “It Was All A Hoax” In an unexpected turn of events, former Green Beret, John Paulus, said on his weblog earlier this morning that he lied about his alleged January 2, 2006 sexual tryst with Clay Aiken. This comes after more than a year of passionate assertion, whereby Paulus was adamant that he had a sexual encounter with Aiken in a North Carolina hotel room. Paulus previously claimed Aiken engaged him in conversation on the “Big Muscle” gay website, and they subsequently met for sex. According to Paulus, he later felt rejected by Aiken after his attempts to contact Aiken were snubbed. Consequently, Paulus talked to the tabloids and press alleging that he was in possession of a towel containing DNA evidence, IM chat transcripts, and incriminating nude webcam shots of Aiken. Paulus passed two lie detector tests for the National Enquirer, his initial contact. As of March 2, 2007, John Paulus is singing a different tune. According to Paulus, he was recruited by a group of eight people in July of 2005 to carry out a plot to discredit Aiken’s straight-arrow image and portray him as a promiscuous homosexual. Paulus is claiming they located him from the “Big Muscle” gay website… “They saw me there and that I was muscular, attractive, and from NC. and persuaded me to help them. So we worked out this scheme over 6 months and put it into place going over ever detail. I even took 3 prior lie detector test so that I could pass one by any media that gave me one.” According to Paulus, “… it was nothing but a story concocted by another Idols fans and I was nothing, but the front person in this scheme.” What about the evidence previously offered up by Paulus? Said Paulus, “Oh what about the cumrag? Used a prop. And the cell phone calls? They were calls made by “haters” to my phone. And the hotel room? There was really a room 207 and I really did check in and I did walk with someone into the room.” “Clay and I never met nor have we ever had sex.” All of this begs the question, why would John Paulus participate in such a scheme and then cling to it so tenaciously for more than a year? Paulus explained, “My only compensation was that they would get me in touch with Lucas to do porno.” In his estimation, Paulus’ porn flick, for Lucas Entertainment, New York City, paid his bills for an entire year. After Paulus initially went public with his allegations, last year, he claimed that some of Aikens’ fans (also known as Claymates) sent threatening emails and death threats, telephoned him at his job, and got him fired from his job, prompting him to contact the FBI for protection. An added incentive for Paulus to stick with his story, after his Lucas Entertainment deal, was… “Because Claymates pissed me off and it was fun messing with them.” He got his porn deal, he messed with the Claymates; so what caused John Paulus to do this sudden about face and claim that his liaison with Aiken was all part of a grand scheme in which he played only a small role? When asked, Paulus explained that his co-conspirators were offended by his apparently softening stance on Aiken, and he felt they were attempting to discredit him…. “Because when I told the haters I was over this and didn’t want to be a part of their game and I defended Clay by saying he looked good and happy on Kimmel they attacked me and said I was a traitor. I can not go on lying for them and destroying a good person.” Amongst those, who Paulus alleged were involved, included an accused blog owner who goes by the name of “Percocet” and owns the “Clay Aiken Fraud Squad” blog, formerly named, “Rabid Claymates Exposed”. Percocet denied that she had any involvement in, or knowledge of, the “scheme” that Paulus spoke of. “I am not, and to the best of my knowledge, noone on my blog is in any kind of cooperation with JP. It is becoming clear how insane he is. You can read his e-mails that he sent to me earlier tonight in my blog comments at 411. JP is just concocting a big story.” Paulus went on to say, “I’d be willing to have a press conference admitting that this was all a lie and that Clay and I never met nor did he ever solicit me for sex and that as far as I know he is straight.” http://theclayaikenblog.wordpress.com/2007/03/02/john-paulus-sayit-was-all-a-hoa x/

You are incorrect, John Paulus did recant his story and said he was paid by a group of fans to set Clay Aiken up.