Eminem Struggled With Depression After Proofs Murder Message Board and Comments

That is so sad he die proof he is just as good eminem both like brothers god bless you proof hurtz I am fan just like I am eminem fan you made him to be something thank you... I love you both I lost my uncle not too long ago on labor day miss you uncle earl you will be miss .......

I agree with all of this having lost a dear friend of mine (Alan Miller aka Dr. Christopher S. Hyatt) in 2008. Not only did I lose him due to his death from cancer, but I had left the west due to a family emergency and had not even talked to him a year before his death, not knowing he would pass away like that. And, one of the last things he said to me when I was in Vegas, "I will stay alive for you." I still battle the grief and am surrounded by all of his work. But to say that Proof was "everything" to D12 is unfair to the existing members. I saw D12 last summer and they rocked, so to give him credit for the whole group is unfair to the rest of the members, they did an excellent job and its unfortunate Eminem did not show up there to support him. Maybe the venue Magic Stick is too small for him these days. It was sad to see someone else rapping his parts.