P.S. I Love You Movie Review Message Board and Comments

The book was fantastic,im not a big reader but this book I could read over and over again,the book is so believable and I felt that I could really connect with the characters ..but what a big let down the film was, it was so disappointing,the acting was so wooden and poor. I dont know whether I had built up in my head what the characters would look like, but Hilary Swank didnt really do it for me at all, the book is quite serious and the film made it into a comedy. I think you can tell a film will be good in the first ten minutes and I totally switched off. Surely the author should have had a say in the way the film was made..but I suppose she was offered millions so what does she care?!?. I would definetly recommend the book and DONT WATCH THE FILM BEFORE DOING SO.

It is certain that it is a man who has written this review. The audience is not a dumb as you treat them to be! They have their own, choices and dislike. For those studying films, the camrea angels and shakiness may matter. To others what matters is the emotion amd the relativity with real life consequence. All in all, it is not so bad a movie, surely you can see it with your lover once more to understand it better!

I have to absolutely disagree with you!!! This movie is the ultimate chick flick and definitly something to watch. Hilary Swank is a brillant actress and definitly dedicated herself to the character. As for Gerard Butler, he was absolutly worth watching. He connects with Hilary and fits the part almost perfectly. Kudos to the cast and crew of P.S. I Love You