Neal Edelstein

Neal Edelstein

Neal Edelstein Quick Links

Film RSS

Shelter Review


Good
With slick and snaky production values, directors Mans Marlind and Bjorn Stein create a gleefully bonkers thriller. As a result, there are moments of real terror even as the story gets increasingly ridiculous.

Pittsburgh psychiatrist Caroline (Moore) doesn't believe multiple-personality disorder actually exists, even as her psychiatrist father (DeMunn) continually challenges her. His latest test is David (Rhys Meyers), whose alter-egos manifest with an unexplained physicality. As she looks into the case, Caroline's scepticism is shaken by hints that something demonic might be going on here, especially when an agitated woman (Conroy) tells her a scary story about "Satan-worshipping mountain witches". Soon Caroline's brother (Corddry) and daughter (Proulx) are caught up in the mystery as well.

Continue reading: Shelter Review

The Invisible Review


Good
The trailers for The Invisible ask, "How do you solve a murder when the victim is you?" This indeed poses several mysteries, but not the ones the trailer-makers have in mind. First, there's the question of whether the question is grammatically correct (the answer: maybe, but it sure sounds awkward). Then there's the mystery not of how to solve said murder, but where exactly the difficulty lies when you is -- er, are that murder victim. High-school senior Nick Powell, this film's victim, pretty much "solves" his murder while he's being killed (or near-killed); he recognizes and even converses with his assailants. Case closed.

Except that he's dead, of course, but assuming, as The Invisible does, the existence of a rather flexible netherworld between living and death, filling in further details isn't a problem either. When Nick wakes up as a sort of half-ghost, traveling through the land of the living without the ability to be seen or heard while his body lies on the brink of death, his detective skills need only to consist of following the murderers around, overhearing their motivations.

Continue reading: The Invisible Review

The Straight Story Review


Weak
With opening shots of a setting sun and a quaint small town, followed by a sequence involving a man being injured, very slow dialogue, and a woman being unbelievably stupid, and an Angelo Badalmenti rustic score on in the background, one would think that we were in the David Lynch world that we are used to... that this time we would get a cross between "Twin Peaks" and Blue Velvet. But, because we have seen the Disney logo in front of this film, we know that we're in store for something a little more watered down. We know that this film will raise no controversy, will anger no feminists, and that is highly doubtful that David Lynch will have an affair with Sissy Spacek (the fact that he would have to get remarried to his wife in order to do that notwithstanding).

We are not in Lynch's world, and, despite several pieces of stylistic evidence to the contrary, there is no way we're going to enter Lynch's world in The Straight Story.

Continue reading: The Straight Story Review

Lumiere And Company Review


Good
A documentary-ish experiment: Give 40 movie directors the world's first movie camera (the Lumiere cinematograph, 1895) and 52 seconds in which to shoot their own mini-film. Some of the directors go all out (David Lynch and some French people I've never heard of)... and some are pathetic, self-ego-massaging wastes of time (particularly Spike Lee, who uses his 52 seconds trying to get his baby to say "Dada"). Also curious is how many directors made movies about making movies (methinks that's all they know any more). But how often can you see 40 films, the making-of story, and an interview with the director, all in an hour and a half? Once in a lifetime is just about enough.

Mulholland Drive Review


Good
[In the spirit of competition, we present a rare filmcritic.com double review on David Lynch's sure-to-be-controversial Mulholland Drive as well as a feature discussion about the film. For additional, alternate looks at films, check out our feature "Respectfully, Yours." -Ed.]

Christopher Null, not overly impressed

Continue reading: Mulholland Drive Review

Neal Edelstein

Neal Edelstein Quick Links

Film RSS
Advertisement

Contactmusic 2017 Exclusive

Occupation

Filmmaker


Suggested

Bob Dylan's Taste In Music Is Not As Predictable As You Might Have Thought

Bob Dylan's Taste In Music Is Not As Predictable As You Might Have Thought

Ahead of his new album 'Triplicate', Bob Dylan reveals his favourite artists.

Julian Barratt Turns Detective In His New Dark Comedy 'Mindhorn'

Julian Barratt Turns Detective In His New Dark Comedy 'Mindhorn'

'Mindhorn' sees Julian Barratt as a former TV star who pretends to be a detective to nab a killer.

Thurston Moore Combines Music With Mysticism On 'Rock N Roll Consciousness'

Thurston Moore Combines Music With Mysticism On 'Rock N Roll Consciousness'

'Rock N Roll Consciousness' is the new album from former Sonic Youth frontman Thurston Moore.

Advertisement
Blink-182 Joins The Line-Up For Free-Pass NCAA March Madness Music Festival 2017

Blink-182 Joins The Line-Up For Free-Pass NCAA March Madness Music Festival 2017

Blink-182 join headliners Aerosmith and The Chainsmokers for the 2017 NCAA March Madness Music Festival.

Scarlett Johansson Says It's Important Her Daughter Sees Her As An

Scarlett Johansson Says It's Important Her Daughter Sees Her As An "Independent Woman"

Johansson's estranged husband has complained that his access to his daughter is being restricted by her work schedule.

'Marvel's Iron Fist': Co-Creator Slams Viewers Complaining About Show's Whitewashing

'Marvel's Iron Fist': Co-Creator Slams Viewers Complaining About Show's Whitewashing

Iron Fist co-creator Roy Thomas 'tries not think' about the critics of the Netflix/Marvel series, because he has 'so little patience' for them.

Advertisement

Neal Edelstein Movies

Shelter Movie Review

Shelter Movie Review

With slick and snaky production values, directors Mans Marlind and Bjorn Stein create a gleefully...

The Invisible Movie Review

The Invisible Movie Review

The trailers for The Invisible ask, "How do you solve a murder when the victim...

Advertisement
Mulholland Drive Movie Review

Mulholland Drive Movie Review

[In the spirit of competition, we present a rare filmcritic.com double review on David Lynch's...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.