A Walk To Remember Movie Review

A scene from 'A Walk to Remember'

Can a small town's handsome, generically troubled high school bad boy be reformed by the soft-focus love of a plain, virginal minister's daughter? Will finding out that the girl, despite showing no symptoms whatsoever, is dying from Leukemia change the way he feels about her? Will over-scripted, highly telegraphed, mushy and grand romantic gestures follow? Will he be inspired to reach for his dreams because of her?

If you can answer these questions without being spoon-fed 102 minutes of cheaply cloying, saccharine yet flavorless syrup, then congratulations -- you've just saved yourself the price of admission to the trite, two-hanky teen romance "A Walk to Remember."

Adapted from a novel by sap-master Nicholas Sparks ("Message in a Bottle") and directed by the desperately uncreative Adam Shankman ("The Wedding Planner"), this is a movie that launches soggy spitballs of sentimentality in nearly every scene as in-crowd malcontent Landon (the blasé and insincere Shane West) falls for candied outcast Jamie (pop princess Mandy Moore), in spite of her mousy brown hair and burlap sack wardrobe (it's hard to make Mandy Moore look dowdy).

As punishment for getting another kid hospitalized in a hazing incident, Landon is forced to be in the school play (as if they'd have him). Inexplicably cast as the lead the second he walks in, late and surly, to the first cast meeting, he rehearses opposite Jamie until he falls in love with her innocence, purity and unashamed, unadorned individuality.

His cool friends soon diss him (after which the narrative never sets foot in the school again) and Jamie's Bible-thumping but altruistic father (Peter Coyote) treats him with justified suspicion. But while Landon stays true through a tidal wave of maudlin romantic clichés and truly awful dialogue ("This girl's changed you and you don't even know it, man!"), "A Walk to Remember" lacks a single moment of emotional sincerity or even a hint of chemistry between its leads.

Shankman's jarringly uneven direction gives the impression he hasn't the patience for transitioning between episodes of ham-fisted heartstring manipulation. The movie has a Point A, a Point B and a Point C, but the director just jumps from one to the other without any story development in between. This is especially true of any scene concerning Jamie's cancer -- an off-the-shelf melodramatic plot device if there ever was one -- or Landon's romantic gestures designed to demonstrate his dreamy nice-guy transformation.

The only element of "A Walk to Remember" that saves it from being 100-percent pure popcorn poppycock is the surprising breadth and veracity of Mandy Moore's performance. Without appearing to try too hard, she completely sells Jamie's willful naivete and emblematic religious devotion. Her reaching out to Landon isn't the least bit contrived, nor is her determination to find the good in him, even turning the other cheek when he belittles her in front of his buddies in the early stages of their friendship (a la John Travolta in "Grease").

One thing the girl can't seem to do right, however, is lip sync to her own music. The school play is, of course, a musical for which Jamie wrote the songs, affording Moore the opportunity to doll herself up a bit and belt out a couple tunes without breaking character. But just like her performance of Connie Francis' "Stupid Cupid" in "The Princess Diaries" last year, Moore's singing is conspicuously, distractingly pre-recorded.

Write for us

Comments

Mandy Moore Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Mandy Moore

Unsubscribe

Films by Artist: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

A Walk To Remember Rating

" Terrible "

Rating: Rated: PG, Opened: Friday, January 25, 2002

Mandy Moore Photos

Mandy Moore Kelly Osbourne picture 3697540
Mandy Moore picture 3697542
Mandy Moore picture 3697256

Mandy Moore Film Reviews


More Mandy Moore Movies

Mandy Moore Videos

Tangled, Trailer

Tangled, Trailer

Mandy Moore I Could Break Your Heart Any Day of the Week  video

Mandy Moore, I Could Break Your Heart Any Day of the Week - Video

License To Wed, Trailer

License To Wed, Trailer


More Mandy Moore Videos

Breaking News: Woody Harrelson: Putting On Cop Uniform Felt Like HalloweenJim Carrey's Daughter Gets The Boot On American IdolAmerican Idol Contestant Falls Off Stage In HollywoodBelated Hall Of Fame Induction For Smokey Robinson's MiraclesKaty Perry Signs Divorce Papers With Silly Smiley FaceArnie And Sly Sylvester Stallone Join Forces For 'The Tomb'Courteney Cox Confirms 'No Sex Since David''House' And Hugh Laurie Wave Goodbye After 8 SeasonsDon Cornelius' Son Tony: My Father Did Not Commit SuicideAmerican Idol's Symone Black Falls Off Stage, Hits Her HeadSir Roger Moore And Joanna Lumley Spread The Warmth For Elderly Charity DriveSandra Bullock Laughs Off Dating RumoursCelia Imrie Wants Britain's 'Grim' Care Homes AbolishedChelsea Handler Tears Up Remembering Mum On TvBerry Seeks Permission For France MovePeter Mullan Calls For Cops To Nail Pal's KillerEngaged Valance Not Rushing Into MotherhoodScantlin's Wife Wants Prenup InvalidatedLagerfeld Sorry For Adele 'Fat' RemarkNick Cannon Apologises To Ex Christina Milian On Radio ShowStars Walk The Runway For Heart Disease AwarenessChi Cheng Able To Lift His LegArnold Schwarzenegger Has Shoulder Surgery With StalloneRyan Reynolds Recalls Amsterdam Fight Daniel Radcliffe Has Crush On GoslingHugh Laurie's House To End In AprilHalle Berry Wants To Move To FranceGorillaz Releasing Track With Andre3000Jls Support Former X Factor Contestants At The Brit AwardsRidley Scott Planning Prometheus Sequel Natalie Portman Signs Up For Two Movies Harry Styles To Take Up PilatesMadonna Still Being Sued Over Girls Gone Wild?Kelly Osbourne's Dog Mistaken For Rabbit Sarah Harding Splits From Tom AgainSam Worthington's Life On A Ledge Channing Tatum Praises The Vow's RealismDownton Abbey On Pair With Kim Kardashian In Tv RatingsFabio Capello Resigns As England Manager Who Will Replace Him?Safe House Star Ryan Reynolds On 'World's Sexiest Man' FeudDavid Ginola Rushed To Hospital After Serious Skiing AccidentSpielberg's 'The River' Spooks Critics Into Mixed ReceptionThe Secret Garden Party Celebrates 10Th Birthday And Announces Initial Line UpThe Amazing Spider Man Trailer Hints At Brash, Bolder SuperheroMary Ann Ochota, Former Model, Sends 'Time Team' Into MeltdownRiver Cottage Fire Leaves Hugh Fearnley House Severely DamagedNicole Scherzinger Spotted On Late Night Date With Lewis HamiltonAbraham Lincoln Turns Vampire Hunter In Tim Burton FlickAmber Portwood, Teen Mom Star, Facing 5 Years In PrisonChanning Tatum: 'The Vow Won't Be The Last Time I Strip Off'Plan B Announces Ill Manors, The Album And The MovieAlex Polizzi Won't Fix Her Weight With DietsHarry Redknapp Found Not Guilty Of Tax Evasion ChargesNew Spiderman Trailer Is Released And Gets Mixed ReceptionSpielberg's 'The River' Spooks Critics In Season OpenerShakira Awarded Prestigious French Government HonourColeen Rooney's Blackmailers Jailed For 'Despicable' Act