The Twilight Saga: Eclipse Movie Review

Part 3 of Stephenie Meyer's blockbuster tale continues the downward spiral of moping. It's efficiently made, with a few moments of energy and levity, but everyone really needs to lighten up.

Even though they're now pledged to be together forever, Bella (Stewart) and her dreamy vampire boyfriend Edward (Pattinson) are stuck in a gloomy funk. Not only does she have lingering feelings for Edward's mortal enemy, the hard-bodied werewolf Jacob (Lautner), but vengeful vampire Victoria (Howard) is still after her. Meanwhile, an army of young-blood vampires is building in nearby Seattle, mobilised by the hot-headed Riley (Samuel). And a Vulpari delegation, led by pain-monger Jane (Fanning) is on its way to clean up the mess.

Director Slade does manage to crank up the momentum in the film's final act, but before then it's just scene after scene of painfully dull soul-searching as Bella and Edward mumble about true love while Jacob tries to convince Bella that she really loves him. The problem is that Jacob is so much more interesting that it's a no-brainer: not only is he hot-blooded, but he also has a sense of humour. And he refuses to put a shirt on over his outrageously sculpted torso.

But no, Bella yearns for diamond-skinned "old school" Edward. Maybe if Pattinson were allowed to invest a little more personality into the character we might understand why. Or if Stewart actually showed any emotion beyond sulking. Besides Jacob, the most interesting characters are Edward's lively family (including Facinelli, Reed, Greene and Lutz). And Bella's school buddy Jessica (Kendrick) is so much more engaging that we almost wish the film were about her instead.

Audiences who haven't seen the first two films will find the first hour of this one intolerably dreary, and frankly the rest of the film isn't that much better. The effects are decent but never convincing. And the lacklustre pacing, complete with several irrelevant period flashbacks, makes it tediously unfocused. But the premise is still compelling, and if you've made it to this point this chapter is an essential part of the saga. So grit your teeth and suffer through: it's not unwatchable, but it should've been so much better.


gargamel's picture


Clearly,you do not understand human emotions. Intelligent audience,do not need actions, to give interpretation to what is obvious. I'm so glad you belong to the few who finds this film worth trashing than complimenting. You are a very stereotypical critic. You go against what's popular. Your review speaks of mediocricity. Kristen was so right to attack this movie in her own way, NOT TO GET ON ACTING THE CHARACTER, but channel her feeling through the woman she was playing who was described in the book as simple,intelligent,loving and sensitive woman. She just made it look easy because KRISTEN STEWART is all that woman! SO QUIT YOUR ELEMENTARY CRUSADE AND STOP BASHING THE MOVIE AND THE ACTRESS, JUST CRITIC OTHER FILMS, THERE'S SO MANY OUT THERE. WE HAVE SO MUCH WASTAGE, DONT BE ONE OF THEM.

3 years 10 months ago
View Comments

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse Rating

" Weak "

Rating: 12, 2010


More Kristen Stewart

Kristen Stewart Reveals Why She Doesn't Smile For Photos

The star of films including On the Road and Snow White and the Huntsman, Kristen Stewart is often accused of being moody in the mainstream...

Robert Pattinson Talks Briefly About Kristen Stewart

Robert Pattinson has once again opened up about his relationship with ex-girlfriend Kristen Stewart.Robert Pattinson was interviewed by Esquire magazineIn an interview exclusive to Esquire...

Cool Thing Of The Week: Jenny Lewis' "Just One Of The Guys" Video, Featuring Anne Hathaway

Jenny Lewis’ new music video might be the best thing on the internet this week. Not only is the song, Lewis’ new single Just One...

'Snow White and the Huntsmen 2': Frank Darabont In, Kristen Stewart Out

Frank Darabont, the creator of The Walking Dead, is in early talks to direct Snow White and the Huntsman 2 for Universal Pictures and Roth...


Robert Pattinson Flirts With Katy Perry Whilst Living With Kristen Stewart?

Robert Pattinson may be "homeless" but he still has the time to admire his close "friend" Katy Perry. However, as he is rumoured to be...

Kristen Stewart Just Directed Sage and The Saints' Music Video: What's The Verdict?

Actress Kristen Stewart has just added to her Hollywood CV by having a go at directing for a friend’s music video. ‘Take Me To The...

Robert Pattinson Talks Kristen Stewart And Where 'Twilight' Went Wrong

Robert Pattinson has spoken out about Kristen Stewart for the first time since their very high profile split. The pair called it quits in 2013...

Round And Round: Robert Pattinson Admits He And Kristen Stewart Still Talk

Robert Pattinson has yet again fuelled speculation over his relationship with ex-girlfriend Kristen Stewart by suggesting that the two are still very much in contact....