The Return (2006) Movie Review

First off, I don't know what all those fanboys see in ex-"Buffy" Sarah Michelle Geller. In The Return she seems shorter than usual, her head just peeking up over the bottom of the screen. And she's haggard here. Sleep deprived with a head of goth-mop hair that I think is supposed to echo those J-horror trollops in schoolgirl uniforms that are around every horror film corner these days. Speaking of horror, though its ad materials paint it as yet another Japanese styled ghost extravaganza The Return is really just one of those slow reincarnation thrillers that littered video store shelves in the '90s.

Geller plays a vacant waif who's on the run from something bad that happened in Texas. Could it have something to do with the car accident she was in when she was a kid? Or how about that phantom stranger we keep seeing flashbacks of? When Geller does return to Texas on business, she starts seeing things and cutting herself. Saved by a grizzled stonewashed denim guy after a near assault, Geller learns that the secret to her hallucinations, the ghostly stalker, and her sour social life lies somewhere deep in the dusty heart of Texas.

Sure, it's familiar claptrap. But the real problem with The Return is that it's as boring as Geller's hair. This flick crawls. To say that The Return moves slowly would be like saying Andy Warhol's 485-minute static shot of the Empire State Building, Empire, is thrilling. Anytime something remotely intriguing happens, The Return picks up briefly. But at the climax of every one of these scenes the action is suddenly curtailed by Geller waking up and realizing it was all a dream. You can just imagine the frustration after the sixth time this happens.

The Return probably should have been a good film. Director Asif Kapadia's BAFTA-nominated The Warrior was a gorgeous and engaging Indian take on samurai legends. Producer Aaron Ryder has Memento and Donnie Darko on his resume. I guess the problem lies with Gellar and scripter Adam Sussman. Not only is the plot a third-rate rehash of an oft-told tale, but Gellar slouches her way through the role seemingly convinced that if she pouts and mumbles she'll be believable as a disturbed woman. Instead the only thing we come away believing is that she was bored out of her mind making this boring movie.

The Return is surely a low point in the on-going battle to scare U.S. teens from their allowances. Neither frightening nor engaging, the film flits lifelessly around Gellar's hollow performance like a bat around a dim bulb.

Eh, don't bother coming back.

Cast & Crew

Director : Asif Kapadia

Producer : Aaron Ryder, Jeffery Silver

Starring : , Peter O'Brien, , , , J C Mackenzie, Frank Ertl

Comments

rmkowals's picture

rmkowals

No offense but this was a horrible review. You also spelled Gellar wrong for most of it. She played a great character. Granted she did not have a lot of dialogue but she does not need it, she is able to carry scenes just with her actions. It was a bit slow at points but it was beatufilly filmed so that made up for the speed of it. I wish it wasn't marketed so much as a horror movie, it was definitely more a suspense mystery. I suggest watching it a second time...now that you know what happens in the end you will see things in a brand new exciting light.

7 years 6 months ago
Report
View Comments

slipper d's picture

slipper d

I agree. I thought SMG did a good job carrying the film almost single-handed and I wasn't disappointed by the ending. Sounds like the reviewer is a little weary of his trips to the cinema. I tend to pick and choose very carefully what I see and, as a result, cherish my visits to the big screen and am rarely disappointed. Gellar is a very underrated actress in my view and watching this film has encouraged me to seek out some of her other film appearances.

7 years 6 months ago
Report
View Comments

The Return (2006) Rating

" Terrible "

Rating: R, 2006

Advertisement

More Sarah Michelle Gellar

New 'Scooby Doo' Movie Announced In Wake Of Casey Kasem Death

A brand new Scooby Doo movie has been given the green light by Warner Bros. just days after the announcement that the original Shaggy voice...

Sarah Michelle Gellar and David Boreanaz Together Again! But Where Are The Cast of Buffy Now?

We practically fell off our chair with excitement when we saw that Buffy and Angel, sorry, Sarah Michelle Gellar and David Boreanaz have recently been...

The Year's Favourites Are Chosen At The 2014 People's Choice Awards: Full List Of Winners [Photos]

The People's Choice Awards kicks started awards season and the celebrities didn't let down as they came out in force and with style in Los...

Sarah Michelle Gellar Tells Fans Off For Forcefully Trying To Obtain Autographs Outside 'Letterman'

'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' star Sarah Michelle Gellar poses for photographers as she arrives outside the New York studios of 'The Late Show with David...

Advertisement

CBS Plan 'Bad Teacher' Series Based On The Cameron Diaz Film

With the fall line ups for television broadcasters across America being revealed gradually over the past weeks, CBS have thrown a curveball with the announcement...

Sarah Michelle Gellar, Robin Williams And Anna Faris Make An Appearance At CBS Upfront 2013 - Part 2

The biggest stars of the CBS network including 'The Crazy Ones' actors Sarah Michelle Gellar and Robin Williams, and 'Mom' stars Anna Faris and Allison...

The Crazy One: Robin Williams Stuns CBS Advertisers With Cocaine Jokes

Robin Williams plays an unhinged advertising genius in the new CBS comedy The Crazy Ones, with co-star Sarah Michelle Gellar, and the veteran comedian certainly...

Gellar's Baby Name Revealed! Is He Named After Classic Boxer?

Sarah Michelle Gellar's choice of baby name for her second child has finally been revealed, some two months after she and husband Freddie Prinze Jr...

Advertisement