The Republic of Love Movie Review

The DVD case for The Republic of Love engages in a little harmless misinformation. The film is not actually based on a Pulitzer Price-winning novel. It's based on a book written by someone (Carol Shields), who wrote another book (The Stone Diaries), which did win a Pulitzer.

That's some comfort, too, because I can't fathom how a middle-aged romantic tragicomedy like this could possibly win a major award.

At its core is a story of a radio talk show host Tom (Bruce Greenwood) and "mermaid researcher" girlfriend Faye (Emilia Fox). Tom has a string of divorces behind him, the result of being too anxious to fall in love with every girl he meets. Faye is gunshy -- it seems that all of Tom's ex-wives are friends of hers. (And, strangely, she's never met him?)

None of this is played for laughs, really. We're supposed to feel bad for Tom and pine for he and Faye to find something lasting amidst an environment of bleak winter, dysfunctional families, and dying geriatrics. Cold and detached, it's hard to get behind either of these characters, who not only don't seem very right for each other, they don't seem very right for anyone. Case in point: When Tom is jogging with a friend, the guy (right next to him) collapses and keels over dead. Tom doesn't notice: He's distracted by a billboard with his face on it, concerned with the size of his nostrils. As for Faye: A mermaid researcher? I can't put my finger on it, but something just doesn't gel there.

Director Deepa Mehta does nothing to make this palatable. In fact, she goes out of her way to distance us from the story and the characters, most notably through washing the entire movie into total gray, giving it just a hint of color (in the end, the movie brightens up in a particularly awful scene that has animated flowers growing over the frame). Wintry symbolism has never felt so forced -- and in a film that ought to have been played as a romantic comedy, it's never been more out of place, either.

This film is one of Film Movement's simultaneous theatrical/DVD releases -- but I can't find any theater that's showing it. Film Movement is also the sole distributor of its DVDs -- releasing one a month -- so you can't usually get them at Amazon. This one's the exception.


Comments

The Republic of Love Rating

" Weak "

Rating: NR, 2003

Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

Usual Suspects: Breaking Bad, True Detective, GoT, Mad Men, to Duke it Out For Emmy Wins

A superb year for television has seen the Emmy nominations...

Usual Suspects: Breaking Bad, True Detective, GoT, Mad Men, to Duke it Out For Emmy Wins

5 Reasons Why A New Harry Potter Film Is Unlikely

J.K. Rowling really stirred up the cauldron of excitement when she published a new...

Jk Rowling - 5 Reasons Why A New Harry Potter Film Is Unlikely

'Boyhood' Wows Critics & Promises To Change Cinema But Will Audiences Be As Impressed?

Boyhood is a coming-of-age film which literally follows its cast as they...

'Boyhood' Wows Critics & Promises To Change Cinema But Will Audiences Be As Impressed?

Game Of Thrones: George R.R. Martin Hits Back At Death & Health Speculators With F-Bomb

George R.R. Martin is 65. Let's just repeat that - only 65 years old. And, so...

Game Of Thrones: George R.R. Martin Hits Back At Death & Health Speculators With F-Bomb

Could Meghan McCain Join Whoopi Goldberg And Rosie O'Donnell On "The View"?

The View may have found its new Republican panelist. Following the exit...

Could Meghan McCain Join Whoopi Goldberg And Rosie O'Donnell On
Advertisement

5 of The Best Animated Matriarchs (Animatriachs?) Now That Marge Simpson is The Face of MAC Make-Up

Marge Simpson has finally got her moment. After years of living as...

5 of The Best Animated Matriarchs (Animatriachs?) Now That Marge Simpson is The Face of MAC Make-Up

Producer William Orbit Attempts To Defend Britney Spears' Pre Auto-Tune 'Alien'

There's a reason why everything Britney Spears has ever done has been...

Producer William Orbit Attempts To Defend Britney Spears' Pre Auto-Tune 'Alien'


More recommendations

Advertisement