The Quiet Man Movie Review

John Ford and John Wayne conspired to make what is widely regarded as one of their finest films... and it's not a western.

The Quiet Man is as simple as its title. A man with a dark past (Wayne) returns to his homeland in Ireland to reclaim his birthright, falling in love (with local lass Maureen O'Hara) and encountering ornery locals (namely her brother) along the way.

What's the big deal? Wayne gets in a minor scuffle (billed on the DVD box as "the longest brawl ever filmed" -- it sure doesn't look like it). Wayne smooches O'Hara in the rain, getting his shirt all wet. The film is shot in some atrocious color format that makes it look colorized, even though it isn't.

I suspect most fans are drawn to the love story, with Wayne in a rare lovey-dovey role. Sure, he's in that "longest brawl ever," but that consists of a couple of sucker punches followed by some time at the bar. The bulk of the story is endless mush in thatched huts and, well, more bars. And as for that dark past? He's a retired boxer who killed a guy in the ring. Well boo hoo.

To be sure, The Quiet Man has aged poorly, and not even Ford's Best Director Oscar can salvage a tepid romance that takes over two hours to get to its point. That point is a screed against violence (pretty much invalidating both of the Johns' careers), with Wayne's character refusing to fight the brother, no matter what. But love conquers all, in a cliche-ridden denouement.

Maybe it's just my jaded generation, but I was expecting a whole lot more from an Oscar winner. Non-violence has been preached much more effectively than in this flick. In the end, this is just another insanely overrated "classic" which no one can remember why was once given such praise. Try watching it again and see for yourself.

DVD includes commentary from O'Hara, a documentary about Ireland, and remastered audio and video.

Cast & Crew

Director :

Producer : Merian C. Cooper, G.B. Forbes, , L.T. Rosso

Comments

The Quiet Man Rating

" Weak "

Rating: NR, 1952

Advertisement

More John Wayne

John Wayne's Heirs Sue University Over "The Duke" Alcohol Products

The family of actor John Wayne is suing Duke University over the use of the actor's nickname, "The Duke," in a trademark for alcoholic drinks....

The Longest Day Movie Review

D-Day wasn't just fought at Omaha Beach, though Hollywood may have thought so before The Longest Day. D-Day involved a cast of thousands, and...

They Were Expendable Movie Review

One of the worst war movies ever made, They Were Expendable tells the oh-so-serious tale of PT boats during WWII. Set in 1941 (and...

Advertisement