The Outsiders - Comments and Message Board

Comments Return to Article

outsidersfan3's picture

outsidersfan3

I Absolutely LOVE!!!!the book it is amazing and i have read it several times and continue to do so in my lifetime and i love the movie too i own both the book and the movie. the movie leave some parts from the book out though but it is still a great movie

5 years 11 months ago
Report
View Comments

ilovesodapopcurtis's picture

ilovesodapopcurtis

i disagree i think the extended edition is marvellous + much better than the original, it brings out the brotherly bonds + virtually restores rob lowes character sodapop, the middle sensitive brother. although it was great on the original the music on 'the complete novel' is more preppy and brings the movie alive. dont get me wrong i love the original version but all round i think the extended edition is by far the best. well done francis :)

5 years 11 months ago
Report
View Comments

violet's picture

violet

I completely agree- I watched the original so many times when it first came out, and was excited for the dvd disc release. I nearly cried when I heard the new music and how it changed the tone of the scenes. While Ponyboy is being held under water- (a scene that once made me afraid for his life while dissonant cords served the perfect amount of anxiety and tension) the music has been replaced with hotrod surf music that is campy and almost funny. In the scene where he and Dallas get into the argument in the house and then he runs out into the night to johnny's place- the music has gone from fear to rock and roll /surf tunes again. Erasing the fear and aloneness that had once been present. The ending - music change- when Matt Dillon is on the hill- is unforgivable. I used to cry in that scene and instead felt embarrased. I will continue to watch the old edition. The new version only offered some details that were redundant.

7 years 5 months ago
Report
View Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement