The Business of Fancydancing Movie Review

In the press materials for his new film The Business of Fancydancing, writer/director Sherman Alexie calls making the movie -- cheaply and with every crew member sharing in the profits -- "a tribal collaboration of art and capital." After seeing it I call this an extraordinary act of generosity. No auteur is an island, but in The Business of Fancydancing, we can feel the long shadow of Sherman Alexie everywhere. The film is based on a 1992 collection of poems that first brought Alexie to prominence as a writer. Several more books of poetry, novels and short story collections followed, including The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, the basis for the acclaimed film Smoke Signals (1999). Nearly all of Alexie's creative output (oh, he's a national slam poet champion too) has been aimed at a reinterpretation of the Indian (he rejects the term "Native American" and so will I) in contemporary American culture. Tonto, Chief, and the Indian Crying over Pollution gather dust on the shelf of the past. Alexie sees today's Indians (he himself is Spokane/Coeur d'Alene) as raised on rock 'n' roll, aware of their simpleminded portrayal in Hollywood, and conflicted over the legitimacy of reservation life.

Alexie centers this conflict on Seymour Polatkin, a gay poet who has moved off "the rez" to Seattle and enjoys a successful literary career. His best friend Aristotle Joseph went to college with Seymour but dropped out to return to the reservation where "Indians like us belong." Several years later, Seymour has received word that their old friend Mouse the Violin Player has killed himself. Seymour heads back to the rez for the funeral where Anges Roth, his college girlfriend who is both Spokane and Jewish, is a school teacher and now Aristotle's lover.

I've made it sound like an Indian love triangle, but much like Smoke Signals, Fancydancing uses an established genre as an excuse to explore themes like death, memory, and seductive pull of assimilation. Both Seymour and Aristotle have "gone to more funerals than I can remember," mourning friends and loved ones since they were little boys. And yet Seymour hasn't been back to the reservation in five years and doesn't think he has to justify the depth of his Indianess either as an artist or in his lifestyle. Aristotle burns with resentment over not just what he feels is Seymour's cultural betrayal but that his not needing the reservation highlights Aristotle's feelings of dependence and worthlessness. The film's soundtrack captures this struggle with quiet poignancy by using a set of ersatz "Indian chants" with popular English expressions as lyrics.

Like Piñero, another film about a poet and tension between old friends and ethnic identities, the narrative of Fancydancing dips and twirls with improvisation. Scenes told out of order are interspersed with quotes from Seymour's poetry and the main characters doing ritual dances in full Indian dress. It's like an Atom Egoyan film that's been bopped on the head.

Alexie has grown significantly as an artist since writing The Business of Fancydancing almost a decade ago (also around the time I started reading him) as evidenced by the remarkable maturity in this directorial debut. The direction at first seems too flashy by half and yet is surprisingly quiet. He both stays out of his actor's way and doesn't pander to a short attention span-afflicted audience, lengthening scenes uncomfortably and letting the characters develop in the silences. It's a wise decision, helped in no small part by Evan Adams, well-intentioned but quietly cruel as Seymour, and total metamorphosis away from the earnest Thomas Builds-the-Fire he played in Smoke Signals.

In his lesser moments, Sherman Alexie yells his ideas rather than speaks them and the shouting matches between Seymour and Aristotle are overblown and sloppy. Gene Tagaban does what he can with Aristotle, but a character barely emerges from all the speechifying. And yet for the most part, The Business of Fancydancing is a moving, beautiful film, with Alexie assuredly as the helm and us grateful for it.

The DVD includes a commentary track from Alexie and a plethora of deleted scenes.

Fancydancing? Looks like tap.

Cast & Crew

Director :

Producer : , Scott M. Rosenfelt


Comments

The Business of Fancydancing Rating

" Good "

Rating: NR, 2002

Editors Recommendations

President Barack Obama And Wife Michelle Honor Late DJ Frankie Knuckles In Open letter

President Barack Obama and his wife, Michelle, have paid tribute to the late Chicago DJ...

President Barack Obama And Wife Michelle Honor Late DJ Frankie Knuckles In Open letter

We Still Don't Know When Letterman Is Leaving "Late Show" And Neither Does Stephen Colbert, Apparently

Stephen Colbert will be taking the reigns of the Late Show from David Letterman in 2015...

We Still Don't Know When Letterman Is Leaving

Neil Patrick Harris Rants At Fan During 'Hedwig' Show, But Was In Character The Whole Time

The 40 year-old actor's recent Broadway performance of 'Hedwig and the Angry Inch'...

 Neil Patrick Harris Rants At Fan During 'Hedwig' Show, But Was In Character The Whole Time

Moogfest 2014 Gets To The Heart Of Electronic Music With Shows From Kraftwerk And Pet Shop Boys

Moogfest begins in just a few short hours; here's what you have to look forward to.

Moogfest 2014 Gets To The Heart Of Electronic Music With Shows From Kraftwerk And Pet Shop Boys

Snoop Dogg Gives Brian Williams' Rap Of 'Gin And Juice' The Thumbs Up

Don't worry Brian Williams, Snoop Dogg doesn't mind your questionable rendition...

Snoop Dogg Gives Brian Williams' Rap Of 'Gin And Juice' The Thumbs Up

Tori Spelling And Dean McDermott Work Out Their Issues In New Promo For "True Tori"

Tori Spelling and Dean McDermott’s marital troubles are no secret, thanks to their reality...

Tori Spelling - Tori Spelling And Dean McDermott Work Out Their Issues In New Promo For

Iggy Azalea: Fans sexually assaulted me at shows

Iggy Azalea was forced to quite crowd surfing after allegedly being sexually assaulted by fans...

Iggy Azalea - Iggy Azalea: Fans sexually assaulted me at shows

From Bruno Mars To Lady Gaga: Ten Celebrities Who Have Changed Their Names

What’s in a name? Well for some celebrities things might have been very different if they...

From Bruno Mars To Lady Gaga: Ten Celebrities Who Have Changed Their Names

Lindsey Vonn And Elin Nordegren Are "Close Friends" In Hatred U-Turn

Lindsey Vonn and Elin Nordegren have finally settled their differences after months...

Lindsey Vonn And Elin Nordegren Are


More recommendations