Straw Dogs Movie Review

This remake of Sam Peckinpah's 1971 British thriller is deeply unpleasant but very well-made. It's also bravely packed with all kinds of mixed messages that force us to think about some extremely difficult themes.

Hollywood screenwriter David (Marsden) moves to the backwater Mississippi home of his actress wife Amy (Bosworth), who is immediately sucked back into local life. This includes her former flame Charlie (Skarsgard), who is now a contractor working on David and Amy's barn with his chucklehead hunting buddies (Coiro, Powell and Lush). But soon, the tension between Charlie and Amy erupts into sexual violence, as David is taunted about his manhood. And a simple-minded guy (Purcell) turns out to be the catalyst for an eruption of violence.

Writer-director Lurie gives the film a jolt of intelligence that transcends its rather cliched setting. These aren't ordinary rednecks: they're straw dogs, young men whose lives suddenly became meaningless after they stopped being local heroes on the high school football team. So life is about bravado, bar brawls and staying at the top of the pecking order. While Coiro, Powell and Lush are extremely believable in these roles, Skarsgard is far too beautiful and charismatic to be such a dolt. Which actually makes his character darkly intriguing, especially since the performance is so perfectly gauged.

Meanwhile, Marsden and Bosworth are terrific as the happy couple whose life is first shaken and then threatened with total oblivion. Their animalistic reaction is the central theme of the story, and also the most distasteful element in a film that's packed with cruelty, bigotry, murder and rape. That David isn't actually a man until he has killed everyone trying to attack his family is an extremely vile concept.

But then, this is a film about the worst side of humanity, including this cultural definition of masculinity. Scenes are packed with big issues - class and privilege, honesty and politeness, hunting and being hunted, law-abiding and rule-bending - as Lurie digs into the fragile balance of life in small-town America. It's not a pretty picture. And the film is increasingly hard to watch as events turn so violent that thinking of this as exaggerated fiction is the only way to cope with it.

Comments

Straw Dogs Rating

" Good "

Rating: 18, 2011

Advertisement

More James Marsden

A Week In Movies: Fans Line Up For If I Stay, Big Films Shoot In London And L.A., And Trailers Arrive For New Movies Starring Banderas, Renner, Marsden And Mara

Chloe Grace Moretz and Jamie Blackley have been out and about promoting their new teenage tearjerker If I Stay over the past week. First they...

The Best Of Me Trailer

Dawson and Amanda are living the life of the typical movie love story - they spend their time enjoying long summer days and nights together,...

James Marsden Lands Role in HBO's 'Westworld'

HBO is known for big budget television series featuring high calibre stars, and it looks like their latest project is no different. 'Westworld' is based...

The Best Of Me Trailer

Dawson Cole is a high school student who, unlike his peers, prefers his own company rather than anybody else's. He doesn't have girlfriends, and he...

Advertisement

Jennifer Lawrence And Michael Fassbender Among World Premiere Arrivals For 'X-Men: Days Of Future Past' - Part 5

Jennifer Lawrence was a picture of elegance as she swished up and down the red carpet in a classic style blue velvet gown at the...

The Cast Of 'X-Men: Days Of Future Past' Arrive At The World Premiere In New York - Part 6

Among the cast of 'X-Men: Days Of Future Past' that were spotted at the world premiere held at the Jacob Javits Center in New York...

Is 'Walk of Shame' 2014's Biggest Box Office Failure So Far?

If you’re looking for a film this year to live up to its name then why not try Elizabeth Bank’s new movie. Unfortunately for her,...

Walk Of Shame Trailer

Meghan Miles is a reporter whose best friends insist on taking her out and dragging her away from a night in alone wearing sweatpants. She...

Advertisement