New York, I Love You Movie Review

There are 11 captivating short films in this anthology, the second in the Cities of Love series by producers Benbihy and Grasic. But this collection isn't quite as varied or engaging as Paris Je T'Aime.

All of these stories take place in Manhattan, with only one or two brief forays into other boroughs, and they all centre around relatively well-off people, mainly white or Asian. They're also quite serious and emotional, with only brief moments of humour dotted here and there, although some make us smile more than others. Each is about a male-female relationship--marriages, brief encounters, possibilities, life-long companionship. Most have a somewhat gimmicky twist, and a few are intriguingly oblique.

Only a couple films stand out. The most striking visually is Kapur's segment, starring the radiant Christie as a woman in an old-world hotel being tended by a foreign bellhop (LaBeouf). It also feels the most interesting, as the looseness of the late Minghella's script allows the actors to invest subtext into every shot. Also memorable is Marston's slice of old-age life with the fantastic Leachman and Wallach bickering and bantering as they stroll to Coney Island.

The best gag goes, unsurprisingly, to Ratner. And it's also unsurprising that Nair manages to capture a rich blend of ethnic and religious diversity in her understated short. Attal has actually made two films, as Hawke and Q offer a clever take on flirting while Chris Cooper and Wright add weight to their telling glimpse of marriage. Leave it to Bradley Cooper and de Matteo to provide the lustiest segment, written and assembled with wit and skill. While Portman's enigmatic and elegant short packs a quiet punch.

Holding everything together are Balsmeyer's transitional scenes, starring Ohana as a videographer collecting the stories for an art performance and meeting several of the other characters along the way. The pieces that are thus loosely intertwined are filmed with the same warm cinematography and silky-smooth editing. It's just a shame there isn't more variety in the geography, filmmaking styles and in the kinds of characters on screen. Because even though each segment is rather wonderful in its own way, as a whole this feels like a side of New York that we've perhaps already seen on screen.

Comments

New York, I Love You Rating

" Good "

Rating: 15, 2009

Advertisement

More Hayden Christensen

Rachel Bilson Pregnant With Hayden Christensen's Child?

Rachel Bilson is pregnant it was revealed yesterday by various source speaking to a US entertainment website. Multiple sources close to the couple have reportedly...

Takers Trailer

Up until now Gordon Cozier and his bank robber gang have remained one of the most proficient crews in the business. Each robbery is planned...

Advertisement

Awake Trailer

Awake Trailer Awake is a psychological thriller of a man (Hayden Christensen) undergoing heart surgery while experiencing a phenomenon called 'anesthetic awareness,' which leaves him...

Jumper Trailer

Jumper Trailer Based on the book by Steven Gould, Jumper follows a young man (Hayden Christensen) from a broken home who discovers that he's the...

Factory Girl, Trailer Stream Trailer

Factory GirlTrailer StreamNew ClipA beautiful, wealthy young party girl drops out of Radcliffe in 1965 and heads to New York to become Holly Golightly. When...

Advertisement