Jersey Girl Movie Review

Kevin Smith grows up. The writer/director from Red Bank, N.J., temporarily retires his trademark Silent Bob shtick for Jersey Girl, which sticks to a cute but overused plotline, occasionally branching out to include a few (but not enough) sarcastic observations addressing parenthood.

Though it wasn't pre-planned, Smith's film also puts the final nail in the "Bennifer" coffin then begins the resurrection process on Ben Affleck's floundering, Gigli-ravaged career. For the first time in a long while Affleck carries a decent picture, making a stronger connection to Smith's casual dialogue than he does with any of his co-stars.

Hollywood's favorite hunk of wood plays music publicist Ollie Trinke, a Manhattan mover and shaker whose life detours after his wife (Jennifer Lopez) dies giving birth to the couple's daughter, Gertie. Ollie attempts to soldier through, but an on-the-job blunder costs him his cushy gig and sets up a running Will Smith gag that has a satisfying payoff. He moves back to New Jersey with his blue collar father (George Carlin), where he learns to accept his parental responsibilities and become the man Gertie needs him to be.

Jersey gets off to a strong start. Smith writes very well for his longtime leading man, and Affleck sells Ollie's self-centered tendencies better than he does the inevitable sentimental transformation. Ben is most comfortable when he's the sole focus of a scene, so his interactions with love interest Liv Tyler and feisty daughter Raquel Castro are flat. When Affleck selfishly argues with young Gertie about how much he misses his old lifestyle, though, we believe him and feel the pain of his loss.

It's worth mentioning that Jersey is a better looking film than Smith's previous archaic efforts. With legitimate cinematographer Vilmos Zsigmond in tow, Smith experiments with edits, camera pans, wipes, and fades. From a technical standpoint, Jersey is Smith's Titanic, without all that pesky ice and water.

His screenwriting skills, though, still need polish. Smith's comments on parenting are insightful, but he's not focused enough to tackle those issues without avoiding after-school special territory. The conflicts facing these characters are recognizable, their resolutions predictable. Smith intentionally tones down his trademark vulgarity to bring his message to the PG-13 crowd, and slices the cherished edge off his voice in the process.

The DVD includes two feature commentaries (one from a relatively unapologetic Smith and Affleck, one from Smith, producer Scott Mosier, and oddball addition Jason Mewes), plus various behind-the-scenes extras.

Lovin' on Liv.

Comments

Jersey Girl Rating

" OK "

Rating: PG-13, 2004

Advertisement

More Ben Affleck

Ben Affleck Can Relate to Batman's Anger Management Issues

Ben Affleck, who will play Batman in Zack Synder's forthcoming Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice, says he can relate to the Caped Crusader's anger...

Zack Snyder Tweets Picture of Cyberpunk Batmobile from 'Batman v Superman'

Zack Synder, the director of 2016's hugely anticipated superhero movie Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, has tweeted a picture of the Batmobile that will...

Rosamund Pike Suggests 'Gone Girl' Sex Scenes were "Inappropriate"

The British actress Rosamund Pike who stars in David Fincher's forthcoming drama Gone Girl has suggested the sex scenes that she shares in the movie...

Scoot McNairy As The Flash? Green Socks Could Be 'Batman v Superman' Plot Clue

With Ben Affleck as Batman, Henry Cavill as Superman and Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman all making solid appearances in 2016's 'Batman v Superman' movie,...

Advertisement

'Gone Girl' Is Coming - But Did Ben Affleck Do It?

David Fincher's Gone Girl has been billed as the season's 'darkest thriller'. It stars Ben Affleck as Nick Dunne - a man juggling two campaigns:...

Fresh Rumours Emerge Surrounding 'Batman v Superman' Plot

For those desperately looking for nuggets surrounding the upcoming Batman v Superman movie – entitled Dawn of Justice – a juicy new rumor has emerged...

'Batman v Superman' Against 'Captain America 3': Who Would Have Prevailed?

The collaboration of Batman and Superman, two of DC Comics most intense superheroes, has been a project highly anticipated for fans all over the globe...

'Batman v Superman' Doesn't Want To Be Anywhere Near 'Captain America 3'

Warner Bros has brought forward Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice - the follow-up to Man of Steel with Ben Affleck playing the Caped Crusader...

Advertisement