In Your Hands [Contre Toi] Movie Review

Subtle and involving, this dark drama maintains a fierce sense of perspective that never allows any side-plots to distract us. For us and for the central character, the situation is all-consuming, haunting and deeply perplexing.

After her last day at work before going on holiday, maternity doctor Anna (Scott Thomas) returns home to find a man waiting for her. Yann (Marmai) kidnaps her and locks her in a barren room, giving her enough information to figure out why he has her. But she has no idea what he's going to do next. And it seems like he doesn't either, especially as his cruelty shifts into compassion. So when one day she finds the door unlocked, she's not sure if she should report him to the police.

The film opens with Anna's harrowing return home, then fills in the story as she tells it. But the events are so complex that we can understand why she's not sure how to react. Yann is a good-looking young man who's emotionally devastated by the original events that brought them together; he's not a bad man, and yet he has done something terrible. But is her affection for him misplaced? She's not sure, and neither are we.

Filmmaker Doillon plays on this dilemma beautifully, never over-egging the events to let us know how we should respond. She keeps the camera tightly within Anna's point of view, letting us see the conflicting moments that make it difficult to make a definitive response. It's obvious why she would be attracted to this vulnerable, sensitive man though he's her abductor. But can they have a happy ending together?

Scott Thomas and Marmai both deliver transparently brittle performances that make it difficult for us to judge them. Meanwhile, the deliberately evasive filmmaking and acting play to our sympathies, so while if we're shocked by the violence, we understand where it comes from. Acting out of desperation is only human, right? In other words, the cast and crew draw us right into the heart of the situation, then have the nerve to let us sort out how we might respond.

Which is a maddening but refreshing way to tell a story. Especially in preachy times.

Cast & Crew

Director : Lola Doillon

Producer : Saga Blanchard

Starring : , , Jean-Philippe Ecoffey, Marie-Sohna Conde, Marie-Christine Orry, Vinciane Millereau, Sophie Fougere, Jean-Louis Tribes

Comments

In Your Hands [Contre Toi] Rating

" Good "

Rating: 15, 2010

Advertisement

More Kristin Scott Thomas

My Old Lady - Trailer Trailer

Mathias (Kevin Kline) is penniless and pretty down on his luck in New York despite having come from a wealthy family. In what seems like...

Before the Winter Chill Movie Review

Reuniting with filmmaker Philippe Claudel (I've Loved You So Long), Kristin Scott Thomas delivers yet another brittle, understated performance as a woman who isn't always...

The Invisible Woman Movie Review

A fascinating true story becomes a deeply repressed movie in the hands of writer Morgan (The Iron Lady) and actor-director Fiennes. It looks and feels...

The Invisible Woman Trailer

At the height of his career, Charles Dickens finds himself embroiled in one of the biggest personal struggles of his life. While working on a...

Advertisement

Looking For Hortense Trailer

Damien Hauer is a professor of Chinese civilization whose life with his stage director girlfriend Iva Delusi has become rather stagnant and miserable. Things get...

"The Invisible Woman" - Ralph Fiennes' Latest Period Drama Explores The Secret Life Of Charles Dickens [Trailer + Stills]

This year sees the release of one of Ralph Fiennes’ most highly anticipated works, The Invisible Woman, based on the dramatic and secretive personal life...

The Invisible Woman Trailer

Charles Dickens may be famous for having written some of history's greatest stories, but his own life story is probably one of the most touching...

There's A Lot To Love (And Hate) In "Only God Forgives"

There’s a lot to love in Only God Forgives – or hate, depending on where exactly on the love/hate Nicholas Winding Refn spectrum your sympathies...

Advertisement