His Secret Life Movie Review

A scene from 'His Secret Life'

Already tormented by grief over the auto-accident death of her loving husband, an upper-middle class Italian widow receives another psychological blow in "His Secret Life" when going through his personal effects. She discovers he was having an affair. For seven years. With another man.

An emotionally resounding, life-affirming film of surprising connections and affections, the story sees Antonia (Margherita Buy) brought out of her despondency by the determination to face down her husband's lover. But instead she finds herself becoming friends with the sexy, rugged, 30-year-old artist named Michele (Stefano Accorsi), despite receiving a catty cold shoulder at first.

"Now he's gone and I still have to put up with you? No way," Michele protests. "I couldn't even go to his funeral. All I have left is a stack of photographs."

But when Antonia is embraced by Michele's inner circle after making house calls to treat one of his AIDS-stricken friends (she's a doctor), a tentative affinity slowly forms between the two loves of the dead man's life.

Written and directed by Ferzan Ozpetek ("Steam: The Turkish Bath"), the film is ardent, penetrating and poignant as Antonia and Michele surprise themselves, bonding through shared stories of their romantic moments with Massimo (Andrea Renzi) and revealing secrets he kept hidden from one or the other. "Massimo cooked?" Antonia gasps after being told he made a mean meatball. "I'll give you the recipe if you want," replies Michele's kitchen-inclined best friend.

Cologne-model handsome Accorsi and comely, pensive, fresh-faced-at-40 Buy do an admirable job of depicting the growing covenant between their characters, the occasional confusion that goes with it, and the events that remind them how different they are -- especially when it comes to Michele shutting out his sorrow through promiscuous sex. Antonia is quite rattled when she sees her partner in woe being sandwiched between two chiseled lovers during a patio party at Michele's colorfully decaying rooftop loft.

Ozpetek includes some seemingly arbitrary subplots that are at times misleading about who is important to connect with in the picture. A transgender cohort of Michele's, for example, debates whether her brother's funeral is the right place for her family to see her as a woman for the first time. And Antonia's maid cries and prays over Massimo's demise for so long that you may start to wonder if she had been the man's lover as well.

"His Secret Life" (called "Fate Ignoranti" or "Ignorant Fairies" in Italy) also suffers from such strange editing choices that the oddly incongruous last act feels as if a reel might be missing when Antonia changes emotional and existential direction two or three times in as many screen minutes.

But the movie's warmth and human veracity prevail over its weaker elements, allowing the unique story to become comfortable, intimate and affectingly altruistic.

Write for us

Comments

Margherita Buy Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Margherita Buy

Unsubscribe

Films by Artist: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

His Secret Life Rating

" OK "

Rating: Unrated, Opened: Friday, September 20, 2002

Margherita Buy Film Reviews


More Margherita Buy Movies

Breaking News: The Artist Dominates Bafta Awards The Artist A Big Winner At Britain's BaftasHistoric Movies A Time Bomb?Jolie Comes Out Fighting At Berlin News ConferenceStudios Set A February RecordThe Bbc Falls Victim To ScandalMurdoch Hit By New ScandalRachel Mcadams & Tatum Beat Washington & Reynolds To Claim U.S. Box Office Number OneBlake Lively Gifted With Brand New Christian Louboutin Shoe CollectionPlaymate Sues New York Cops For Excessive ForceSienna Miller Records SongSarandon: 'Daughter Was Conceived On Rome's Spanish Steps'Brad Pitt Loved Work As Stripper's DriverRoseanne Barr And Goodman Reuniting On ScreenNicolas Cage Pokes Fun At Himself On Comedy ShowHorror Movie Icon Bill Hinzman Dead At 75The Artist Continues To Dominate Award Season At The BaftasDel Rey Lands A Second Week At Number One In The U.K.Evanescence Star Mccord Devastated By Guitar TheftJennifer Lopez Bares All For Glowing Perfume AdsBeckham Debuts Harper Bags At Fashion Show, Husband David AttendsGreen Convinced M.I.A. Regrets Rude Finger Salute At Super BowlHouston's Family Members Release Statement Thanking Fans For SupportChaka Khan To Join Grammy Tribute To Whitney HoustonJesse Jackson Honours Houston At Her Former ChurchEmotional Bobby Brown Concert Footage Surfaces OnlineJennifer Hudson Struggling With Whitney Houston Tribute RehearsalsHouston's Daughter In HospitalChanning Tatum Is 'Emotional'Kiera Knightley Admits To Having Body InsecuritiesGlen Campbell Announces Farwell Tour, Talks AlzheimersWill Young's Fantasy Videos Whitney Houston Tributes At Pre Grammy Gala And At Grammys AwardsBobby Brown Sobs On Stage After Whitney Houston DeathWhitney Houston's Body Is Moved From Beverly Hills Hotel To MorgueWhitney Houston Was Happy Days Before Her DeathWhitney Houston Dead: 'Could Have Drowned' ReportWhitney Houston Dead 2012: But How Did She Die?Shakira Awarded Prestigious French Government HonourColeen Rooney's Blackmailers Jailed For 'Despicable' Act