For Your Consideration Movie Review

Anyone who watched last year's Oscar ceremony surely had to take a deep breath of exhaustion at what became the culmination of a solid decade of congratulating mediocrity. In the last two decades, Hollywood has offered up more self-deprecation, but it doesn't come close to its flabbergasting self-congratulation, and Oscar is a big part of that. The last time the Academy awarded the best film of the corresponding year was 1993, when it dutifully handed the little gold man to Clint Eastwood's unflinching revisionist western, Unforgiven. So, who better to attack this institute of imbecility than comic revisionist Christopher Guest? As it turns out, For Your Consideration isn't quite the snappy attack dog one might have hoped for. In fact, it comes on with the ferocity of a mildly-disgruntled schnauzer.

It begins with director Jay Berman (Guest, doing the Jewish thing) and his film, Home for Purim, a family drama about a young woman's return home to a dying mother. The mother in question is played by Marilyn Hack (Catherine O'Hara), a washed-up aging actress who is best known for playing a blind prostitute in another film. Through the wonders of the internet, she gets wind of a rumor that she might be nominated for an Academy Award. Shortly after, Victor Allan Miller (the invaluable Harry Shearer), the male lead, gets hint of a nomination for his performance, along with Callie Webb (Parker Posey), who plays the daughter. The buzz makes life sweeter, and inevitably more complicated, for everyone involved, including Callie's boyfriend and co-star Brian (Christopher Moynihan), Victor's agent (Eugene Levy), and the producer (riotous Jennifer Coolidge). It also brings out studio heads (Ricky Gervais and Larry Miller), the PR guy (John Michael Higgins), and two Hollywood news anchors (Fred Willard and Jane Lynch) to make the film more palatable.

Guest's stylistic shift here from his usual mockumentary to a normal narrative structure results in a transitional film. The lack of personal time with the characters distances them from the audience. Guest's cavalcade of miscreants has been proven incredibly adept at bringing out the humor and the humanity in their pleasantly flawed characters for three films straight. However, For Your Consideration's targets seem to be misplaced: He's mocking the actors and actresses that are duped into believing they are going to be overnight celebrities rather than the studios and media circus that manipulate them and the system to turn a bigger profit. Rarely has a film seemed so confidently condescending to its characters. Rather than seeing the mortal foolishness in the actors, we only see their preening egotism flourishing after the nomination whispers. It makes the film seem cruel and cold towards characters that are simply human, and it's out of place for Guest.

That's not to say that Guest's troupe have lost their knack for making people laugh. Their skills at improv seem as sharp and keen as ever, with special kudos to Coolidge and Higgins who steal scenes with venerable glee. The usually dependable Levy (who co-wrote the script) takes a more direct route than in the last two films, leaving his character struggling for laughs. O'Hara, per usual, can't help but be funny and seems to really understand Hack (perfect name, by the way) for the first half of the film. Newfound Guest supporter Gervais isn't given enough screen time, but he still brings springy humor to his scenes, along with Willard and Lynch, who nail their characters with noteworthy shallowness. The spirit of comic bravado can still be felt underneath, but the film is undeniably flawed, almost fatally. Award-worthy it ain't.

Take 57.


For Your Consideration Rating

" Weak "

Rating: PG-13, 2006


More Catherine O'hara

The Right Kind Of Wrong Trailer

Leo Palamino is a failed writer trying to earn a living as a dishwasher while his marriage to Julie rapidly wanes. Things get even more...

Frankenweenie Movie Review

With a snappy sense of childish curiosity and lavishly skilled animation, Tim Burton makes one of his most endearing and enjoyably offbeat movies in years....

A Week In Movies - 12th October 2012

With the 56th BFI London Film Festival up and running, it's red carpet night every night in Leicester Square. And it all kicked off earlier...

Frankenweenie Trailer

Victor Frankenstein is a young fanatic of science and loves making home movies with his pet bull terrier and best friend, Sparky. On discovering that...


Winona Ryder 'Frankenweenie' Character Image

FRANKENWEENIE Rating: TBC UK Release Date: 17 October, 2012 Director: Tim Burton Producers: Tim Burton, Allison Abbate Voice talent: Winona Ryder,...

Frankenweenie Trailer

Victor Frankenstein is a young boy with an interest in science and home movies. The star of his home movies is his beloved bull...

A Monster In Paris Trailer

Paris, 1910. Delivery guy Raoul, and his friend, ladies' man Emile, are accidentally let loose in a laboratory belonging to a professor. Their monkey friend,...

Killers Trailer

Watch the trailer for Killers When Jen Kornfeldt takes a trip to Europe to get over a bad break up, finding a new love is...