Five Broken Cameras Movie Review

It's impossible to understate the importance of this documentary in helping us see exactly what life is like in occupied Palestine. By sticking so closely to one perspective, the film opens itself to accusations of manipulation and one-sidedness. But that's precisely the point as it captures details of the daily situation in Israel and Palestine that we have never seen before. And it's assembled with real skill by journalist Emad Burnat.

Burnat decided to start documenting his life when his son Gibreel was born in 2005. Using a home video camera, he shows the family home in the village of Bil'in with his wife perturbed Soraya and kids. And we also meet three important friends: the likeable Bassem (who everyone calls "Phil"), hotheaded Adeeb and nice-guy Daba. So as the Israelis partition his family's olive grove with a huge fence and no man's land, Burnat and his friends begin peaceful protests. But the Israeli police and settlers respond with abuse, teargas, arrests and even bullets. Even when they take the police to court to get their land back, it takes five years for the Israelis to accept the verdict.

Through all of this, Burnat watches Gibreel's reaction to the world around him. His first childish experiences involve violence and fear, and he simply can't understand why anyone would want to shoot his friends. He grows up seeing Israelis as nothing but masked thugs who wave their big guns rather than talk. As one camera after another is smashed or shot by the soldiers, Burnat tenaciously captures some very big events, including a friend's death and his own near-fatal car crash.

Without ever saying so, it's clear that what we're seeing is a present-day form of Apartheid. And Burnat's voiceover injects not only lucid narration of the events but also his own thoughts and feelings, which makes the film that much more involving. Israel's supporters may complain that this doesn't give their side of the story, but that's not what this film is documenting: it's showing you how it feels to be oppressed in your own home, stripped of freedoms and basic rights. And this makes it utterly unmissable.

Rich Cline

Cast & Crew

Director : Emad Burnat, Guy Davidi

Producer : Guy Davidi

Starring : Emad Burnat, Soraya Burna, Bassem Abu-Rahmat, Adeeb Abu-Rahma, Daba Abu-Rahma, Gibreel Burnat, Mohammed Burnat, Yasin Burnat

Comments

Five Broken Cameras Rating

" Extraordinary "

Rating: 15, 2012

Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

Gabrielle Union Contacts FBI After Topless Photos Of Actress Leak Online

Gabrielle Union is just one of the many female celebrities who have had their...

Gabrielle Union Contacts FBI After Topless Photos Of Actress Leak Online

Colin Farrell Confirms He Has Landed Lead Role In 'True Detective'

Colin Farrell is the next huge Hollywood actor to take his talents to the...

Colin Farrell Confirms He Has Landed Lead Role In 'True Detective'

One Direction's Zayn Malik Recalls Receiving "Family Planning Advice" From Russell Brand In Autobiography Extract

When a young man needs some much needed advice on the risks of unprotected...

One Direction's Zayn Malik Recalls Receiving

Jennifer Lopez Ft. Iggy Azalea - Booty

Jennifer Lopez has released the music video for her new single, 'Booty', after it was remixed by Australian rapper...

Jennifer Lopez - Booty Video

Angelina Jolie Set To Direct Conservationist Richard Leakey Biopic 'Africa'

Angelina Jolie has already found her next directorial project, and it is another...

Angelina Jolie Set To Direct Conservationist Richard Leakey Biopic 'Africa'

Eminem Ft. Sia - Guts Over Fear

Ahead of his upcoming compilation album, 'Shady XV', Eminem has released a lyric video for his August 2014...

Eminem - Guts Over Fear Video

Emma Watson's First U.N. Women Goodwill Ambassador Speech Targets Gender Inequality

Emma Watson, who was newly appointed a United Nations Goodwill Ambassador...

Emma Watson's First  U.N. Women Goodwill Ambassador Speech Targets Gender Inequality

Kite - Trailer

When her father, a police officer investigating a human trafficking case, is murdered along with her mother, Sawa...

Kite Trailer

HBO's "On The Run" Special Has Us Teary-Eyed And Loving Everything About The Carter Family

Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Beyonce and Jay Z’s On The Run special on HBO...

HBO's
Advertisement