Combination Platter Movie Review

Robert (Jeffrey Lau) works at the Szechuan Inn in the burgeoning Chinatown of Flushing, Queens. Robert is from Hong Kong and, like most of his co-workers, he doesn't have his green card. He speaks Cantonese and a little English, whereas the kitchen staff speaks mostly Mandarin and the American-born Chinese hostess and white busboy only English. The hostess is picking up a few words in Cantonese, such as "mild," for the sake of the cooks. The busboy wants to know how to say "fuck you." Robert's only friend is another Hong Kong immigrant who has a plan to get Robert his green card; when the Chinese-American woman he introduces Robert to asks for fifty thousand dollars, rather than the twenty-five thousand agreed upon, to provide him with citizenship by marrying him, Robert is introduced instead to a white American woman named Claire (Colleen O'Brien). Robert wonders why this American woman would want to date him. Maybe she's just lonely, his friend explains. Robert and Claire spend time together, but Robert's limited English prevents any real relationship from developing and his conscience nags at him. Meanwhile Immigration is sweeping Chinese restaurants in the area, hauling undocumented workers away in handcuffs. How long before Robert gets hauled away, too?

Combination Platter, which took the screenwriting award at Sundance in 1993 and subsequently played a limited theatrical run to positive reviews, is in many ways the ideal independent feature. Its outside-the-mainstream perspective -- that of an undocumented, specifically Asian immigrant -- is one that a studio would never touch; or, if it did, the perspective would be broadened so that, like Dirty Pretty Things, the film encompassed the experiences of outsiders of many different types. Combination Platter remains specific to the plight of Chinese immigrants, and it recasts a familiar American landscape in a new light. While all of us are familiar with restaurants like the Szechuan Inn, bare apartments like the one Robert retires to nightly, the bodegas and delis that dot urban street corners, Robert's necessarily low-profile existence is more or less confined to a circuit of locations like these, and the viewer is introduced to an America parallel to, but more restricted than, the one we know. In Robert's small world, Americans are the outsiders, customers mostly, although all of them are to be treated with suspicion since any of them -- and especially the customers -- might prove to be Immigration agents. Meanwhile Robert's Chinese acquaintances are sometimes nearly as foreign to him as the Americans: there are the Mandarin-speakers, those more assimilated than he, and Chinese such as the hostess who were born and raised in America.

It's a strange world, and director Tony Chan, whose sole feature this is, presents it with candor and honesty rather than the kind of self-conscious quirkiness that mars many small independent films. Time and again Chan makes narrative choices that are more true-to-life than magical; Robert's relationship with Claire, for instance, concludes in a way that is probable, given the facts of Robert's situation, but atypical in terms of screen romance. A subplot about a fellow server at the Szechuan Inn with a gambling problem is treated in similarly non-Hollywood terms. The problems that arise with the film -- the cinematography, for example, is imaginative in the kitchen scenes but hopelessly cramped on the floor of the restaurant -- are those common to low-budget features like Combination Platter. What recommends it is its candor and uniqueness. It's a small, but very enjoyable film.

Combination Platter is newly available, sans extras, on DVD.

Cast & Crew

Director :

Producer : ,

Starring : , Colleen O'Brien, Lester "Chit-Man" Chan

Comments

Combination Platter Rating

" Good "

Rating: NR, 1993

Advertisement

Editors Recommendations

George Clooney Set To Receive The Cecil B. DeMille Award at The 2015 Golden Globe Awards

At the moment George Clooney’s personal and professional life couldn’t be...

George Clooney Set To Receive The Cecil B. DeMille Award at The 2015 Golden Globe Awards

Kanye West Defends Himself In Recent Wheelchair Controversy: "I'm A Married Christian Man With A Family"

Kanye West can't seem to go through a full week without making headlines...

Kanye West Defends Himself In Recent Wheelchair Controversy:

Our Guide To This Year's Mercury Music Prize Nominations

The 24th edition of the annual Barclaycard Mercury Prize is due to be held on Wednesday...

Our Guide To This Year's Mercury Music Prize Nominations

Hot Tub Time Machine 2 - Trailer

Following their adventure in 1986, Nick (Craig Robinson) and Jacob (Clark Duke) are visiting their old friend, Lou (Rob...

Hot Tub Time Machine 2 Trailer

Matt Damon And Paul Greengrass In Talks To Reunite For New 'Bourne' Sequel

One of the most intricate spy stories may be coming back to the big-screen!...

Matt Damon And Paul Greengrass In Talks To Reunite For New 'Bourne' Sequel

Effie Gray - Trailer

When young Effie Grey (Dakota Fanning) is married to John Ruskin (Greg Wise), a man ten years older than her, she...

Effie Gray Trailer

Alicia Keys - We Are Here Video

With an intended late 2014 release date for her upcoming sixth studio album...

Alicia Keys - We Are Here Video

Ariana Grande Talks Big Sean, And Writing "Sexual" Songs In Her Early Teens

Ariana Grande was first seen as a young star on Nickelodeon, but she is...

Ariana Grande Talks Big Sean, And Writing

Cat Stevens/Yusaf Islam Announces Dates For North American Tour For First Time Since 1970s

Yusuf Islam, formerly known as Cat Stevens, has announced that this coming...

Cat Stevens/Yusaf Islam Announces Dates For North American Tour For First Time Since 1970s
Advertisement