Camille Claudel 1915 Movie Review

With a stripped-down, bare-faced performance, Juliette Binoche is utterly wonderful in this tense French drama. Based on the real story of artist Camille Claudel, who was locked in an asylum by her family, the film is an unofficial sequel to the 1988 biopic. And it also continues to provocatively explore the impact of religion in society that has infused writer-director Bruno Dumont's work from La Vie de Jesus (1997) to Outside Satan (2011).

The film picks up Camille's story after she has split up with the sculptor Rodin and established herself as an artist in Paris. But her family is worried that she is living the wrong kind of life, so in 1913 they had her committed to an isolated psychiatric hospital. Over the next two years, her doctor (Robery Leroy) and the attending nuns know that she shouldn't be here, especially since the constant noise from the inmates interferes with any attempt to carry on with her work. When her younger brother Paul (Jean-Luc Vincent) comes for a visit, Camille hopes that he'll finally agree to let her out, but his intense religious believes convince him that the arts are evil and that the best way to care for his sister is to cruelly lock her away.

Yes, Dumont is drawing all kinds of parallels here with modern society and the fears people have of art they don't understand, which would probably include many of Dumont's films. But aside from a brief section that centres on Paul, the film is tightly focussed on Camille, and Binoche lets us see right through her. It's a wrenchingly raw performance that reveals all of Camille's conflicting inner emotions, with glimmers of hope and even bliss as well as the deep yearning to have her old life back so she can once again express herself artistically. By locking in so closely on Camille, Dumont and Binoche force us to experience her incarceration with her, including the daily irritations and small mercies.

Sometimes this depiction of mental patients is darkly disturbing, bordering on horrific, but Dumont finds the humanity in each of the other patients, as well as the nuns, doctor and priest. It's the church itself that's the villain here, controlling society so fully that no one has a chance for proper treatment. This hospital is utterly cut off from the outside world: Camille can get snatches of news about the Great War, but nothing of the arts culture she so desperately misses being a part of. And in a sense, Camille is also trapped here by her own faith, as she is obedient to even this injustice. But Dumont never pounds any of these themes heavily; he just plants the seeds and lets us take it from there.

Cast & Crew

Director :

Producer : , , Muriel Merlin

Starring : , Jean-Luc Vincent, Robert Leroy, Marion Keller, Emmanuel Kauffman, Armelle Leroy-Rolland

Comments

Camille Claudel 1915 Rating

" Excellent "

Rating: 15, 2013

Advertisement

More Juliette Binoche

March 24, 1997: The Day Lauren Bacall Was Robbed of an Oscar

After over 40-plus years as one of Hollywood's leading ladies, Lauren Bacall - who died on Tuesday (August 12, 2014) aged 89 - had to...

Camille Claudel 1915 Movie Review

With a stripped-down, bare-faced performance, Juliette Binoche is utterly wonderful in this tense French drama. Based on the real story of artist Camille Claudel, who...

In "Clouds Of Sils Maria" Kristen Stewart And Juliette Binoche Dive Deep Into The Psychology Of Fame And Age

If you follow Kristen Stewart’s career with the irrational passion that this writer does, you’ll no doubt have already seen the trailer for her new...

Words And Pictures Trailer

Jack Marcus is an eccentric English teacher at a prep school in the country who used to be intensely passionate about his line of work....

Advertisement

'Godzilla' Is More Growling Than Roaring Success, But Still... [Trailer]

It's going to be a big weekend for Godzilla: the monster action reboot has been teasing its entrance for months with irresistibly gloomy and stylised...

Godzilla Movie Review

For a blockbuster about gigantic radioactive monsters, this is a remarkably humane movie. But then that's no surprise for a film from Gareth Edwards, whose...

A Thousand Times Good Night Movie Review

Too prickly for mainstream crowds and rather emotionally sentimental for arthouse fans, this drama may have trouble finding an audience. But it's a striking story...

Kristen Stewart Turns 24, As Attention Turns To 'Clouds of Sils Maria'

Kristen Stewart has turned 24 today (April 9, 2014) and the actress has a pretty big year ahead as she continues her post-Twilight movie career...

Advertisement