Benny's Video Movie Review

It's long been a staple of psychological profiling and often debated furiously, but the assumption that violent movies actually make people violent has some merit. How could it not, to some degree? I can remember very clearly stepping out of Teenage Ninja Mutant Turtles in high school and hoping, praying, that someone would try to jump me on the way back to my car so I could get into some sort of kung fu fight. Sure, it would have been geeky, spastic kung fu, and, sure, I would have been beaten senseless, but I was just so pumped up I would've taken on Jet Li. The question isn't does violence inspire violence. The question is: To what extent? Where does that influence end?

We're bombarded almost daily with disturbing news snippets about teens run amok, filming their attacks gloatingly and enjoying them at parties. Forget Girls Gone Wild, nowadays it's Teens Gone Wilding. Is this the end result of a violent movie culture? Bad parenting? Terrible genetics? All of the above? If I watched Teenage Ninja Mutant Turtles enough times (I know, I know, it's a PG movie with puppets, but still...) would I be transformed into the sociopathic killer at the heart of Michael Haneke's Benny's Video?

Haneke, the incredibly gifted filmmaker who wowed audiences with The Piano Teacher and Caché, might say yes. And while it isn't surprising that Haneke condemns Hollywood and horror movies for dulling the sense of children who watch violent movies, the casual, almost hackneyed, mode in which he makes his argument is.

Benny's Video is the second film in Haneke's "Glaciation Trilogy", so called for the "emotional glaciation" of humanity explored in the films. (The first is The Seventh Continent (1989).) The film follows the slow but inevitable trajectory of violence in the life of Benny (Arno Frisch), an alienated but bright kid obsessed with violent images. He watches gory horror films in his bedroom, left to his own devices by parents who pride themselves on making sure he has his freedom. Benny's most prized clip is the slaughter of a pig that he filmed himself. Benny watches it repeatedly, playing it in slow motion, studying the pixels of violent death. He meets a girl at the local video store and invites her back to his place and shows her some of his films including the pig killing. He shows her the weapon used to kill the pig (he's smuggled it home) and then, with the camera trained on the girl, he kills her. Without any emotional response, Benny watches the murder of the girl repetitively, robotically. His parents then fret about how to cover it up.

The message here is simple and the moral couldn't be any plainer. And that's the problem with Benny's Video. For Haneke no explanation is needed, Benny has been turned into a sociopath by his consumption of violent images and his parent's non-disciplinary approach to rearing him. It's black and white. The audience cannot come to any other conclusion. Haneke has decided for us. Fittingly, we are also never given insight into Benny. He remains a machine, remote and inert. And in the end, with a character that repellent and a message so heavy handed, there is no need to commit ourselves to this bitter, merciless film.

Cast & Crew

Director :

Producer : , Bernard Lang

Starring : , , , Ingrid Strassner, Stephanie Brehme


Comments

Benny's Video Rating

" Grim "

Rating: NR, 1992

Editors Recommendations

No, AC/DC Are Not Splitting Up After All. Probably.

It looks like AC/DC fans can breathe a sigh of relief, because rumors of the band’s...

No, AC/DC Are Not Splitting Up After All. Probably.

Allergic Reaction To Blame For Miley Cyrus' Cancelled Tuesday Gig

Miley Cyrus has had it rough this week, as the star has been hospitalized for a severe allergic...

Allergic Reaction To Blame For Miley Cyrus' Cancelled Tuesday Gig

'Transcendence': Negative Reviews For Johnny Depp's 'Lone Ranger' Comeback

‘Transcendence’ is a stern Springtime test for Johnny Depp; the 50-year-old actor mooted...

'Transcendence': Negative Reviews For Johnny Depp's 'Lone Ranger' Comeback

Paul Walker's Brothers Brought In By Universal To Complete Late Actor's "Fast & Furious 7" Scenes

The team behind Fast & Furious 7 has come up with a untraditional solution to finish...

Paul Walker's Brothers Brought In By Universal To Complete Late Actor's

Game of Thrones' Jack Gleeson On Joffrey, Screen Deaths And His Indefinite Retirement

Let’s get the spoiler alert out of the way first: if you haven’t seen Season 4 Episode 2...

Game of Thrones' Jack Gleeson On Joffrey, Screen Deaths And His Indefinite Retirement

Why Did Nobody Watch The 'Mad Men' Season 7 Premiere?

We're not sure what everyone was watching on Sunday night, but the season seven premiere...

Why Did Nobody Watch The 'Mad Men' Season 7 Premiere?

The Next 'Breaking Bad'? 'Fargo' Ep. 1 Is A Must-See [Video]

New television series Fargo premiered last night on FX, giving American audiences...

The Next 'Breaking Bad'? 'Fargo' Ep. 1 Is A Must-See [Video]

Lindsay Lohan's Mother, Dina, Loses Driving Licence After Pleading Guilty To DUI

A member of the Lohan family has ran into trouble with the law, yet again...

Lindsay Lohan's Mother, Dina, Loses Driving Licence After Pleading Guilty To DUI

The First 'Gone Girl' Trailer is Weird And Different To Other Trailers

“I did not kill my wife!” exclaims Ben Affleck in the first official trailer for David Fincher’s...

The First 'Gone Girl' Trailer is Weird And Different To Other Trailers


More recommendations