Is 'Captain America: The Winter Solider' The Best Marvel Movie? We Compare The Reviews

Page 1 of 212

As American fans are gearing up to experience Captain America: The Winter Solider, the reviews are coming in and it looks like this could be Marvel’s greatest offering yet. As the ninth installment from the Marvel Cinematic Universive, Captain America: The Winter Solider has a lot of competition if it wants to be known as Marvel's finest movie. Just to compare, we’ve taken a look back at the reviews for Marvel’s previous cinematic outings to see just how Captain America: The Winter Solider really measures up.

Is Captain America: The Winter Soldier really the best Marvel movie?Is Captain America: The Winter Soldier really the best Marvel movie?

Iron Man (2008)

If you can, cast your mind back to 2008, when we had our first instalment of the Marvel cinematic universe and Robert Downey Jr dawned the Iron Man suit for the first time. In the film that kicked it all off, Downey delivered a career resurrecting performance and the critics lined up to praise the movie. The consensus from Rotten Tomatoes reads. ‘director Jon Favreau and star Robert Downey make this smart, high impact superhero movie one that even non-comics fans can enjoy’ and the movie holds a 93% rating on the site.

The Incredible Hulk (2008)

Just over two months later, the second Marvel instalment, The Incredible Hulk, came our way, with Edward Norton taking on the role. The character had previously had a millennial movie outing in 2003, but this reboot set to reimagine the Hulk giving him a new backstory. Reviews were mostly favourable, with Rotten Tomatoes saying it ‘provides the action and excitement to please comic book fans and re-ignite this fledgling franchise’, overall however, its fresh rating only stands at 67%, comparatively lower than Iron Man.

Iron Man 2 (2010)

Downey Jnr returned to our screens in 2010 in a sequel to the successful Iron Man and the third instalment in Marvel’s cinematic universe. The film introduced audiences to Scarlett Johansson’s character who would later become the Black Widow. Whilst it beat its predecessor at the box office critics found the second Iron Man instalment not quite as exciting as the first. Rotten Tomatoes rounds up the reception by saying, ‘it isn't quite the breath of fresh air that Iron Man was, but this sequel comes close with solid performances and an action-packed plot’ and puts its fresh rating at 73%.

Chris Hemsworth as ThorChris Hemsworth as Thor

Thor (2011)

Next came the turn of Thor, who got his big screen outing in 2011 with Chris Hemsworth in the title role and Tom Hiddleston as his adoptive brother and foe Loki. Mostly critics responded positively to the god of thunder on the big screen, which certainly delivered on the action front. Rotten Tomatoes calls it ‘a dazzling blockbuster that tempers its sweeping scope with wit, humour, and human drama,Thor is mighty Marvel entertainment’ and gives it a 77% fresh rating, putting it above the Hulk's debut but below Iron Man’s.

Next page: Captain America: The First Avenger, The Avengers, Iron Man 3

Page 1 of 212


Tags: Robert Downey Jr - Chris Evans - Chris Hemsworth


More Robert Downey Jr

Robert Downey Jr: "Guardians of the Galaxy is the Best Marvel Movie Ever"

And so it's official. It must be. Iron Man said it. Yep, that's right: Robert Downey Jr himself has proclaimed Guardians of the Galaxy to...

DiCaprio, Johansson, Laurie: A Sneak Peak At Celebrity Auditions

TV and film superstars often don’t seem like real people. They live on a screen in our front room, or occasionally on a bigger screen...

How Sandra Bullock Became The Highest Paid Actress In Hollywood

The results of Forbes annual celebrity rich list are in and it is with a certain amount of surprise thatSandra Bullockwas the highest paid film...

Lead Film Roles That Could Have Looked Very Different

With Robert Downey Jr fitting so perfectly as likeable irritant Tony Stark, Christian Bale slipping so easily into the tortured billionaire psyche of Bruce Wayne...


Marvel's "Avengers: Age Of Ultron" Trailer Debuted At SDCC And Looked Awesome, Probably.

Marvel kicked off promotion for Avengers: Age of Ultron early at SDCC and, as with everything else related to the franchise, they made a massive...

Marvel's Comic-Con Panel Was Packed With "Ultron" Stars And "Guardians" Footage

No one is surprised that Marvel had big things prepared for their Comic-Con panel, after all it’s the biggest industry event of the year. Those,...

Those Colin Farrell for 'Iron Man 4' Rumors Refuse To Die

Rumors are abound that seminal Iron Man actor, Robert Downey Jr, will not be returning for a fourth instalment as the man in the super...

Marvel Announces Release Date for Unknown Movie - What Could It Be?

Last week Marvel studios took the unusual step of announcing five upcoming movie release dates stretching into 2019 without actually announcing what movies they would...



Robert Downey Jr Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Robert Downey Jr

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All