We Were Soldiers

"Good"

We Were Soldiers Review


Post September 11 cinema has seen its share of war movies designed to evoke and sustain a sense of American patriotism. In the last few months, we've re-visited the war in Kosovo (Behind Enemy Lines), the war in Somalia (Black Hawk Down), and most recently, World War II (Hart's War). We Were Soldiers is the latest in the onslaught, a story based on the true accounts of the first bloody battle of the Vietnam War. With so many war films recently released, We Were Soldiers has a difficult task as it tries to ride the patriotism express.

We Were Soldiers is based on the book We Were Soldiers Once...And Young written by Lieutenant Colonel Harold Moore and Joseph L. Galloway, the only journalist willing to go into the front lines to capture a first hand account of the war. In the film, Mel Gibson plays Harold Moore, a down-to-earth officer who is responsible for leading a group of innocent, naive young men into the area of Vietnam known as "The Valley of Death." But not soon after Lt. Col. Moore and his troops touch down, their position is compromised and they find themselves outnumbered almost 5 to 1. The American soldiers engage in a deadly battle for control of the area.

We Were Soldiers takes a different approach to the war story theme by addressing the emotional toll the war has on the soldiers and the families they left behind. The first third of the movie moves very slowly as it attempts to establish the relationships between the husbands and their families, and the military brass and their men. We learn that Moore is a family man who prides himself as much on his wife, Julie (Madeleine Stowe), and their five young children, as he does on his military career and his troops. Moore congratulates Lt. Jack Geoghegan (Chris Klein) and his wife Barbara (Keri Russell) on the birth of their first child as the two pray together before heading into battle.

While at war, we're introduced to journalist Joe Galloway (Barry Pepper). Despite the strong military background of his family, Galloway wants to capture the war through images and writings so that people back in America can understand what happens on the front lines. During the height of the battle, Command Sergeant Major Basil Plumley (Sam Elliott) instructs Galloway to trade his camera for a gun. Though Galloway takes to battle like the others and even carries a soldier's charred body to a rescue chopper, he eventually throws his gun down and returns to taking pictures.

The telling of the human aspect of the war is not limited to the events that unfold in the American camp. We are also given interesting views into the strategy used by the Vietnamese during battle, as well as their sorrow when they pick up their fallen comrades. But the focus of the film is clearly on Moore and Galloway, the only two characters that have any degree of depth--all others are drawn extremely thin. Sgt. Maj. Plumley's sole purpose is to provide some scenes of comic relief between the orders he barks at the troops; Lt. Geoghegan is given one key scene in the beginning, but later he is only seen once before he ends up as a casualty of war.

Back at home, the only screen time given to tell the war's impact on the wives and families is when they receive the tragic news that their husbands and fathers have died in battle. We never see their struggle to raise their families alone, or the immediacy to scrape up whatever information they could on the war and the status of their loved ones. We never see the trouble Julie has in addressing the concerns her young children have for their father being at war, or the difficulty Barbara has being a young mother with a newborn child.

Despite its best intentions, We Were Soldiers is just another in a long line of graphic war movies depicted in realistic detail. The cinematography is very striking and has a journalistic feel, as if we are on the front lines looking in on the action as told through the lens of Galloway's camera. As soldiers are shot and wounded, their blood splatters on the lens (and thus, the movie screen). Many of the battle scenes are shown in slow motion, using quick edits that are choreographed to moving scores and songs meant to evoke emotion. We really feel like we're with those troops as they push through the Valley of Death.

The humanistic approach behind We Were Soldiers is well intended, but the concept is not fully realized in the short amount of time devoted to the movie. If the battle sequences had been shortened and the film's opening scenes tightened up, it's possible this theme could have worked to the film's advantage and provided the right sentiment to sustain our current sense of patriotism. Though certainly not a bad film, it fails to give us the complete picture of how the battle impacted the key players and sadly, We Were Soldiers will be remembered more for the gritty war scenes than the emotional toll on those it meant to show.

The DVD features commentary from Wallace, 10 deleted scenes, and an interview with Madeleine Stowe's wig. The only one of those I really cared to see, unfortunately, doesn't really exist.

We were very happy soldiers.



We Were Soldiers

Facts and Figures

Run time: 138 mins

In Theaters: Friday 1st March 2002

Box Office USA: $78.1M

Box Office Worldwide: $114.7M

Budget: $75M

Distributed by: Paramount Pictures

Production compaines: Paramount Pictures, Icon Productions

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 3 / 5

Rotten Tomatoes: 63%
Fresh: 90 Rotten: 53

IMDB: 7.1 / 10

Cast & Crew

Director:

Starring: as Lt. Col. Hal Moore, as Maj. Bruce 'Snake' Crandall, as Julie Moore, as Sgt. Maj. Basil Plumley, as 2nd Lt. Jack Geoghegan, as Barbara Geoghegan, as Joe Galloway, as Capt. Tom Metsker, as 2nd Lt. Henry Herrick, as Capt. Tony Nadal, Robert Bagnell as 1st Lt. Charlie Hastings, Blake Heron as Sp4 Galen Bungum, Josh Daugherty as Sp4 Robert Ouellette, as Capt. Matt Dillon, as Capt. Robert Edwards, Erik MacArthur as Sp4 Russell Adams, Mark McCracken as Capt. Ed 'Too Tall' Freeman, as Sp4 Bill Beck, Duong Don as Lt. Col. Nguyen Huu An, as Sgt. Ernie Savage

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Hampstead Movie Review

Hampstead Movie Review

Deliberately appealing to older audiences, this undemanding comedy-drama comes with a hint of social relevance...

The Book of Henry Movie Review

The Book of Henry Movie Review

Apparently, this offbeat script had been making the rounds in Hollywood for some 20 years...

Transformers: The Last Knight Movie Review

Transformers: The Last Knight Movie Review

With this fifth Transformers movie, it seems clear that Michael Bay is still trying to...

Churchill Movie Review

Churchill Movie Review

This drama about the iconic British prime minister tells a darkly personal story set over...

Gifted Movie Review

Gifted Movie Review

This is one of those films that dances right up to the edge of soapy...

Whitney: Can I Be Me Movie Review

Whitney: Can I Be Me Movie Review

Notorious British filmmaker Nick Broomfield teams up with Austrian music documentary producer Rudi Dolezal to...

The Mummy Movie Review

The Mummy Movie Review

To launch their new Dark Universe franchise, Universal has taken an approach that mixes murky...

Advertisement
My Cousin Rachel Movie Review

My Cousin Rachel Movie Review

Daphne du Maurier's 1951 mystery-romance novel has been adapted for theatre, radio, TV and film,...

Wilson Movie Review

Wilson Movie Review

It's never helpful when a comedy becomes a bit too smug about its own quirkiness....

Interlude in Prague Movie Review

Interlude in Prague Movie Review

A fictionalised story from the life of Wolfgang Mozart, this lavishly produced period drama is...

The Hippopotamus Movie Review

The Hippopotamus Movie Review

This British satirical comedy may be a bit of a mess, but since it's based...

Detour Movie Review

Detour Movie Review

This may look like a rather typical American indie thriller, but British filmmaker Christopher Smith...

Wonder Woman Movie Review

Wonder Woman Movie Review

Boldly optimistic, this action-packed adventure breathes fresh life into the DC universe with a welcome...

Baywatch Movie Review

Baywatch Movie Review

Clearly, it's a risky proposition adapting a cheesy vintage TV series for the big screen:...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.