To Be or Not to Be (1942)

"Excellent"

To Be or Not to Be (1942) Review


Decades before Roberto Benigni was romanticizing the Holocaust and Mel Brooks was supposedly courting Nazi controversy on Broadway, Ernst Lubitsch made To Be or Not to Be, a tart little comedy about the Nazi invasion of Poland which, a few glitches aside, was all the more daring for having been made during the war itself, when its outcome was hardly certain. Unfortunately, Brooks remade the film in his own manner some 40 years afterward, substituting most of Lubitsch's wit with his brand of shtick - not as awful as it could have been, but definitely not a patch on the original.

To Be or Not to Be opens in 1939 on the eve of war, with a Warsaw theater troupe rehearsing a satire called Gestapo, which has been ordered shut down by the government, for fear of offending Hitler. The troupe's stars are Maria and Joseph Tura - a self-absorbed flirt and a preening ham who wouldn't know acting if it smacked him in the face - who couldn't be less interested in the outside world, until it comes crashing in. Maria (Carole Lombard, all smoky elegance) is carrying on an affair with handsome pilot Stanislav Sobinski (Robert Stack, shockingly fresh-faced and clear-voiced), while Joseph (a nimbly verbal Jack Benny) seems almost more perturbed by the fact that Sobinski walks out on his Hamlet soliloquy every night than the fact that he's doing so to meet backstage with Maria.

This Warsaw love triangle actually has enough spark to it that Lubitsch could have made a whole film out of it, but he had bigger things in mind, and so comes the Nazi invasion. After a quick montage, Warsaw is occupied, with the underground fighting hard, and pilots who escaped to England (including Sobinski) manning planes in the RAF's Polish Squadron. Then a quick plot twist later, we're in an espionage film in which the Turas have to work together with Sobinski (parachuted back into Poland by the Allies) to stop a traitor from delivering to the Gestapo a list naming people in the underground. To do so, an elaborate scheme is concocted (fortunately they had that theater full of Nazi uniforms from the shuttered play), packed with mistaken identities, duplicity and bad acting (as the director puts it, watching Joseph head out to impersonate a Gestapo officer, "I hate to leave my country in the hands of a ham"). Not surprisingly, these actors have to put on the performance of a lifetime, most memorably the moment when Greenberg (Felix Bressart), previously relegated to minor roles in their Shakespeare productions, gets to do his long-rehearsed Shylock speech, only it's in front of Hitler's personal guard.

Such fast transitions from backstage farce to wartime drama and cloak-and-dagger mechanics should have resulted in an unholy mess of a film. But, while there are some tonal inconsistencies (as well as some factual ones, like how all these Germans, Brits, and Poles all seem to speak the same, mostly-accent-free, language), this is for the most part a gracefully handled and extremely funny comedy. Lubitsch somehow manages to lampoon the Nazis (who are always breaking into "Heil Hitler!" whenever there's a lull in conversation) without ever lessening the depths of their evil - when a Gestapo officer says about seeing Joseph Tura on stage, "What he did to Shakespeare, we are now doing to Poland," it's simultaneously hilarious and chilling, like the film as a whole.

The Warner Bros. DVD of To Be or Not to Be is a spare package, with only a Jack Benny short and a wartime promo for savings bonds. The picture transfer is only passable, with a fair number of flickers and scratches.

To be.



Facts and Figures

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 4 / 5

Cast & Crew

Director:

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Zoolander 2 Movie Review

Zoolander 2 Movie Review

With virtually the same blend of wit and idiocy as the 2001 original, this fashion-scene...

A Bigger Splash Movie Review

A Bigger Splash Movie Review

Italian filmmaker Luca Guadagnino (I Am Love) reteams with Tilda Swinton for this fresh, tricky...

Deadpool Movie Review

Deadpool Movie Review

Both the filmmakers and the characters on-screen are so pleased with themselves that this might...

Trumbo Movie Review

Trumbo Movie Review

An entertaining film about sobering true events, this is the story of notorious screenwriter Dalton...

Goosebumps Movie Review

Goosebumps Movie Review

Mixing the action, comedy and horror from novelist R.L. Stein's books into a family-friendly package,...

Dad's Army Movie Review

Dad's Army Movie Review

The beloved 1970s British sit-com gets the big screen treatment, although there's been very little...

Spotlight Movie Review

Spotlight Movie Review

This film demonstrates that you don't need guns to make an exciting thriller. Based on...

Advertisement
13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi Movie Review

13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi Movie Review

Not the subtlest director working in Hollywood, Michael Bay brings his surging machismo to this...

Dirty Grandpa Movie Review

Dirty Grandpa Movie Review

There's nothing clever about this deliberately rude and vulgar comedy, but certain audiences will find...

The Big Short Movie Review

The Big Short Movie Review

Smart and snappy, this comedy is one of the scariest films of the year, using...

The 5th Wave Movie Review

The 5th Wave Movie Review

Also based on the first in a trilogy of post-apocalyptic teen novels, this thriller feels...

Ride Along 2 Movie Review

Ride Along 2 Movie Review

Ice Cube and Kevin Hart reteam for a sequel no one really asked for, following...

Room Movie Review

Room Movie Review

One of the most extraordinary films of the year, this drama cleverly weaves in events...

Creed Movie Review

Creed Movie Review

While this film is basically Rocky VII, it's also much more than that, and perhaps...

A Perfect Day Movie Review

A Perfect Day Movie Review

An irreverent comedy in the style of the original M.A.S.H., this wartime romp takes an...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.