The Secret

"Terrible"

The Secret Review


The Secret's trailer surfaced on the Internet in 2002, and for years I waited and wondered why it was taking an eternity for the movie to hit theaters. Finally, in 2007, the movie came out in French theaters, and just recently it went straight to DVD in the United States. And now that I've finally watched it, it's crystal clear why The Secret was kept on the down low: Boy, is it a bad movie -- and an incredible waste of an intriguing premise.

You can't help but feel ever so curious about how the characters are going to get themselves out of this conundrum: Upon awakening after a car accident, Hannah (Lili Taylor) realizes she's in possession of her daughter Sam's body (Olivia Thirlby). Hannah's husband Benjamin (David Duchovny) is in a tough spot: He loves his wife to death (and wants to do nasty things to her) but she's trapped in their 16-year-old daughter's body. What's a guy to do?

Given its premise, The Secret has the potential to explore dark, taboo topics, but director Vince Perez chooses to explore family values instead -- in particular, the idea that parents fail to understand their children. The movie in this way is essentially a Cinemax-style remake of Freaky Friday, only this time we're dealing with one body instead of two, and a sexually frustrated Duchovny, who deserves an Oscar for his ability to portray a piece of cardboard. How freaking stupid is that?

The film is surprisingly rated R, perhaps because we learn about Sam's secretly naughty life as Hannah takes it over. Sam's just a teen, but she's already having sex with not just one but (gasp) two boys! And she does a lot of drugs. And she writes in a diary. Quite a bold move on Vincent Perez's part -- to reveal the shocking truth that teenagers have sex and do drugs. What's he got in store for us next? Maybe a movie about an American sushi restaurant where most of the chefs aren't actually Japanese?

You have to hand it to Perez, though, for accomplishing the perplexing task of making a movie feel rushed while dragging it on for too long. It takes about five minutes for Hannah to convince Benjamin she's taken over their daughter's body, and all it takes him is a web search of "Scientific Research" to figure out what caused the spirit swap. After getting the complicated part over with, Perez devotes the rest of the movie to yawn-inducing scenes of Benjamin and Hannah/Sam yelling at each other. Their arguments can be summed up as, "I want to have sex with you, but I can't!" and "I want to have sex with you, too, but you won't do it with me!"

The other part Perez rushes is the resolution. Without giving away the ending, I'll just say the movie so easily resolves itself that its title is completely misleading, because there isn't a secret to begin with.

It's best, though, to keep this movie a secret -- quietly tucked under a pile of DVDs in the clearance section -- where Perez can pretend it never came to be.

The DVD includes interviews with each of the cast members and a behind-the-scenes featurette.

Aka Si j'étais toi.



The Secret

Facts and Figures

In Theaters: Thursday 13th September 2007

Budget: $15 thousand

Distributed by: Gravitas

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 1 / 5

IMDB: 5.6 / 10

Cast & Crew

Director:

Producer: , India Osborne,

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Alice Through the Looking Glass Movie Review

Alice Through the Looking Glass Movie Review

This much more light-hearted sequel reinvigorates the franchise after Disney's quirky but murky 2010 reboot...

Love & Friendship Movie Review

Love & Friendship Movie Review

Acclaimed filmmaker Whit Stillman reunites the stars of his 1998 drama The Last Days of...

Money Monster Movie Review

Money Monster Movie Review

A sleekly made thriller with a sparky sense of humour, this is also a rare...

X-Men: Apocalypse Movie Review

X-Men: Apocalypse Movie Review

This closing chapter of the First Class trilogy falls into the same trap as The...

Sing Street Movie Review

Sing Street Movie Review

A buoyant celebration of the power of music, this is the third blissfully entertaining musical...

Departure Movie Review

Departure Movie Review

Complex, dark and very moving, this British drama never makes things easy for the audience,...

Everybody Wants Some!! Movie Review

Everybody Wants Some!! Movie Review

Richard Linklater loosely follows on from two of his most acclaimed films with this lively...

Advertisement
Our Kind of Traitor Movie Review

Our Kind of Traitor Movie Review

John le Carre's novel is adapted with plenty of inventive style into a remarkably personal...

The Angry Birds Movie Movie Review

The Angry Birds Movie Movie Review

There's nothing particularly memorable about this frantic animated romp, which adapts the iconic phone-app game...

Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising [Bad Neighbours 2] Movie Review

Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising [Bad Neighbours 2] Movie Review

While it's amusing and sometimes very funny, there's an air of desperation about this sequel...

Florence Foster Jenkins Movie Review

Florence Foster Jenkins Movie Review

Although this comedy-drama seems to have been written specifically to give Meryl Streep a chance...

I Saw the Light Movie Review

I Saw the Light Movie Review

Writer-director Marc Abraham gets ambitious with this biopic about iconic country music star Hank Williams,...

Captain America: Civil War Movie Review

Captain America: Civil War Movie Review

After the formulaic thrills of The Winter Soldier and Age of Ultron, Marvel's Avengers were...

Son of Saul Movie Review

Son of Saul Movie Review

From Hungary, this year's Oscar-winning foreign film is a remarkably fresh take on the Holocaust...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.