Many Biblical epics have graced the screen but few have made any effort to match the casting with the geography. The Nativity Story is a notable exception. In a narrative long since detached from the holiday that celebrates it, Israelite Mary (Keisha Castle-Hughes), living under Roman rule in, well, zero B.C., sees a vision in which the angel Gabriel (Alexander Siddig) tells her that she will conceive a child by the Holy Spirit. Cue the scratching of the record.
Mary takes the news a whole lot better than her family, including Joseph (Oscar Isaac) her new husband from an arranged marriage. No sooner does he have a dream that helps him get with the program than their paranoid King Herod (Ciarán Hinds) decrees a census in which all men must return to the place of their birth with their families. So, Joseph and Mary are off to Bethlehem, and for the rest of the story, see the first couple chapters of Luke or, in a pinch, Linus' speech from A Charlie Brown Christmas.
The culture and setting of the film have a feeling of authenticity that, intentionally or not, serves as a bit of counter-programming in a time when many Middle Eastern (or Middle Eastern-looking -- Castle-Hughes is Australian) faces receive ignorant, knee-jerk associations with terrorists. It's not much of a coincidence that the reason given for the Pope missing the premiere of The Nativity Story at the Vatican (the first film to premiere there) involved preparation for a trip to Turkey to mend Christian/Muslim relations.
Unfortunately, social healing may be all the film has to offer. In spite of a plethora of plot the film never really feels like it's going anywhere. Part of the problem is that we never really get to know Mary and Joseph, and on a fundamental level, it's their story. In one scene, Mary and Joseph discuss the impending birth in a very frank and vulnerable way, but that's the only window we get. Given that the director is Thirteen helmer Catherine Hardwicke, that's particularly disappointing. One of the hallmarks of her debut was the raw, complex emotions of the characters. Here the performances, while admirably natural, betray no depth.
Hardwicke, while capturing the rugged beauty of the terrain, doesn't lend a directorial eye to much else. The film lacks a visual stamp, subtracting one more possible point of entry into the story. In the end, that may be the greatest factor working against the film; it lacks a point of view.
Artistically, The Nativity Story may do no more than competently tell its eponymous tale, but if it also serves to encourage audiences to associate a dark complexion and a thick beard with Joseph instead of Bin Laden, that may be an accomplishment of greater proportions.
Where ya going with that donkey, anyway?
In Theaters: Friday 1st December 2006
Box Office USA: $37.6M
Box Office Worldwide: 46
Distributed by: New Line Cinema
Production compaines: New Line Cinema, Sound for Film
Contactmusic.com: 3 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 38%
Fresh: 49 Rotten: 79
IMDB: 6.7 / 10
Director: Catherine Hardwicke
Producer: Marty Bowen, Wyck Godfrey
Screenwriter: Mike Rich
Starring: Keisha Castle-Hughes as Maria, Oscar Isaac as Joseph, Hiam Abbass as Anna, Shaun Toub as Joachim, Ciarán Hinds as Herodes der Große, Shohreh Aghdashloo as Elisabeth, Stanley Townsend as Zacharias, Alexander Siddig as Der Engel Gabriel, Nadim Sawalha as Melchior, Eriq Ebouaney as Balthasar, Stefan Kalipha as Kaspar, Alessandro Giuggioli as Herodes Antipas, Farida Ouchani as Ruth, Saïd Amadis as Tero, Maria Giovanna Donzelli as Marias Freundin, Francesca Piliero as Marias Freundin, Serge Feuillard as Hoherpriester, Kais Nashif as Benjamin, Andy Lucas as Steuereinnehmer, Tomer Sisley as Steuereinnehmer, Jeffery Kissoon as Architekt des Herodes, Lucia Zotti as Tante der Elisabeth, Monica Contini as Cousine der Elisabeth, Paola Sotgiu as Hebamme, Gabrielle Scharnitzky as Wahrsagerin, Stewart Scudamore as Straßenprediger, Chiara Di Pede as Das entführte Mädchen, Zinedine Soualem as Der Vater des entführten Mädchens, Luciana Paolicelli as Die Mutter des entführten Mädchens, Damir Todorovic as Römischer Soldat Steuereinnahme, Matt Patresi as Römischer Wachsoldat, Yvonne Sciò as Komplizin des Taschendiebs, Andrea Bruschi as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Jean-Claude Deret as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Angela Iurilli as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Francesco Martoccia as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Alessandro Piscitelli as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Maria Antonietta DiMonte as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Emilio Adrisani as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Emilia Fortunato as Einwohner von Bethlehem, Shelby Young as Naomi, Sami Samir as Taschendieb, Ted Rusoff as Strabo
One of the strongest action thrillers in recent years, this gripping movie cleverly casts actors...
Meryl Streep is having so much fun playing an ageing rocker that the audience only...
Like James Bond, wilfully anonymous driver Frank Martin is reborn as a new actor without...
Like an antidote to vacuous blockbusters, this intelligent, thoughtful drama packs more intensity into a...
This biopic gallops through the career of groundbreaking gangsta rappers N.W.A, working its way through...
Basically the perfect summer movie, this lightweight drama has a great-looking cast and plenty of...
As the ghoul from the 2012 horror hit stalks a new family, this sequel's sharply...
After setting the scene with vivid characters and some insightful interaction, the plot of this...