Proof (2005)

"Bad"

Proof (2005) Review


The Broadway hit Proof put playwright David Auburn's name on the map, earned him a shelf full of prizes (from Tony to Pulitzer), and reminded those of us who stopped paying attention that Mary-Louise Parker was a star. A movie adaptation was inevitable, though a drastic mishandling of the material was not.

Familiarity with Auburn's stage presentation may breed contempt for this version, which feels distinctly off-kilter from its first frames. Mysteries that held water longer in the theater instead land like Doc Marten's on a flimsy piece of plywood here. Director John Madden samples a chatty, analytical approach to his literal translation but gets swept up in stagy, awkward, and all-too-deliberate line readings. Much like last year's ill-conceived Phantom of the Opera, this movie has few cinematic qualities that elevate it above a tedious and emotionless play rehearsal shot on location.

Need a reason as to why Proof goes so horribly wrong? Look no further than Rebecca Miller's screenwriting credit. Her unique penchant for shrill incoherence taints the bulk of this piece, reverting interesting stage characters into whirling dervishes of catty despair. The picture opens on Catherine (a sullen Gwyneth Paltrow) as she engages her browbeating father, Robert (Anthony Hopkins), in a convoluted conversation on personal sanity and death. Before we're able to settle into their disjointed groove, a vital twist that drives Auburn's play is unceremoniously revealed: Robert himself is dead and Catherine's coping with the loss.

The math genius's demise invites unwelcome intruders into Catherine's closed-off and relatively unstable existence. Her domineering sister, Claire (Hope Davis), arrives from New York to assess the fragile situation. At the same time, Robert's protégé Hal (a hopelessly miscast Jake Gyllenhaal) strives to filter through the legendary mathematician's journals in hopes of finding publishable work. Claire wants to protect Catherine, Hal wants to sleep with her, and Catherine just wants to know if she's going to follow her father's mentally ill footsteps.

Spending time with these characters is a chore. Catherine's incessant tap dance around her own stability drives us crazy. Paltrow strives for wounded but consistently lands on whiny, selfish, and unpleasant. She and Gyllenhaal share levels of chemistry last seen between the Titanic and an iceberg. Paltrow's harsh interactions are one-sided rants fired at unsuspecting co-stars, and only Hopkins shows the restraint needed to balance the actress's overbearing approach. She elicits no sympathy as she alienates Davis, Gyllenhaal, Hopkins and - in turn - the audience.

When we arrive at the central mystery of Madden's version - whether or not Catherine actually wrote a groundbreaking mathematical proof found in her father's office - the saddest realization is that we don't care about the answer. Arguments normally reserved for Sunday morning political talk shows chip away at the film's integrity until we're left with a bitter core. Character motivations flip faster than cards on a blackjack table. Catherine claims authorship of the proof, then she ignores it. Hal refutes her ability to write it then forces himself on her (at her father's wake, no less). Proof can't conjure a single legitimate thread, or an emotion to back it up. "What is the point of all these questions?" shrieks Catherine when those around her get too close. If only Proof had a legitimate answer.

You're fat. You want me to prove it?



Facts and Figures

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 1.5 / 5

Cast & Crew

Director:

Producer: John N. Hart, ,

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

Contactmusic 2017 Exclusive

New Movies

Hidden Figures Movie Review

Hidden Figures Movie Review

This film recounts such a great true story that we don't mind the fact that...

The Founder Movie Review

The Founder Movie Review

This is the story of Ray Kroc, the man who created the concept of McDonald's....

John Wick: Chapter 2 Movie Review

John Wick: Chapter 2 Movie Review

Keanu Reeves picks up his supremely efficient hitman immediately where the 2015 original left him:...

Fences Movie Review

Fences Movie Review

After winning Tony Awards on Broadway, Denzel Washington and Viola Davis reteam for a film...

The Lego Batman Movie Movie Review

The Lego Batman Movie Movie Review

A spin-off from 2014's awesome The Lego Movie, this raucously paced action-comedy is proof that...

The Space Between Us Movie Review

The Space Between Us Movie Review

While the premise of this movie makes it look like a sci-fi adventure, the truth...

Toni Erdmann Movie Review

Toni Erdmann Movie Review

On paper, the idea of a two-hour 40-minute German comedy may not seem very promising,...

Advertisement
Gold Movie Review

Gold Movie Review

Based on a true story, this lively and sometimes outrageous adventure is packed with twists...

Loving Movie Review

Loving Movie Review

While this film tackles a huge issue in the history of race relations in America,...

T2 Trainspotting Movie Review

T2 Trainspotting Movie Review

It's been 20 years since we last saw four freewheeling young junkies from Edinburgh spiral...

Hacksaw Ridge Movie Review

Hacksaw Ridge Movie Review

Based on an astounding true story, this battlefield drama mixes warm emotion with intense action...

Sing Movie Review

Sing Movie Review

The quality of the animation in this musical comedy may not be up to Pixar...

Jackie Movie Review

Jackie Movie Review

Rather than make a standard biopic about the most famous First Lady in American history,...

Split Movie Review

Split Movie Review

After a few badly received sci-fi blockbusters, M. Night Shyamalan returned to his earthier style...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.