Yes he can! Mickey Blue Eyes, against all odds, is nothing short of fall-down funny - on par with Notting Hill, South Park, and Austin Powers 2 as one of the best comedies of the summer.
The plot involves Grant's milquetoast auctioneer, who, after three months of dating, proposes to his girlfriend (Tripplehorn), whom he doesn't realize is the daughter of a major New York Mafioso (Caan). Hilarity ensues when the mob family tries to rein Grant in for various money laundering schemes, dubbing him "Mickey Blue Eyes." Enter the FBI, and accidental shooting, nocturnal shallow-grave burials, and a payback/revenge scheme, and you've got some pretty weighty elements here - but Blue Eyes usually makes the most of them all - in a comic sense, of course.
Don't be fooled: Grant carries this picture all by his lonesome. Tripplehorn is fine, but uninspiring. The mob guys are broadly drawn stereotypes. Caan is playing his usual tough guy and doesn't have a whole lot of screen time. With the exception of a few bizarre supporting characters (see also Notting Hill, again), Hugh Grant owns this show.
And therein we see what a comic talent he really is. Essentially, Mickey Blue Eyes is a fish out of water tale, only the water finds the fish this time around. And watching this fish squirm is one hell of a good time.
Am I Blue?
Run time: 102 mins
In Theaters: Friday 20th August 1999
Distributed by: Warner Home Video
Production compaines: Castle Rock Entertainment, Warner Bros.
Contactmusic.com: 4 / 5
Rotten Tomatoes: 45%
Fresh: 34 Rotten: 42
IMDB: 5.8 / 10
Director: Kelly Makin
Starring: Hugh Grant as Michael Felgate, James Caan as Frank Vitale, Jeanne Tripplehorn as Gina Vitale, Burt Young as Vito Graziosi, James Fox as Philip Cromwell, Joe Viterelli as Vinnie D'Agostino, Gerry Becker as FBI Agent Bob Connell, Maddie Corman as Carol the Photographer, Tony Darrow as Angel, Paul Lazar as Ritchie Vitale, Vincent Pastore as Al, Frank Pellegrino as Sante, Scott Thompson as FBI Agent Lewis, John Ventimiglia as Johnny Graziosi