Mental Review

Even for a riotous Australian black comedy, this film packs in just a bit too much chaos. It's consistently smart and funny, with lively characters and especially witty dialog, but some of the sideroads never go anywhere. Still, there's so much terrific material in here that it's well worth a look for fans of the genre. And it's great to see Collette return home to reunite with her Muriel's Wedding director P.J. Hogan nearly 20 years after they launched their careers.

The story centres on suburban housewife Shirley (Gibney), who is obsessed with The Sound of Music and wishes her unruly family was more like the Von Trapps. But no, her husband (LaPaglia) is the town's philandering mayor, and their five daughters all think they're mentally ill. Then when Shirley herself ends up in a psych ward, Dad brings in the drifter Shaz (Collette) to watch the girls. She takes no prisoners, whipping them into shape while trying to give them some self-respect. She also shows them that the people society considers "normal" are probably crazier than they are. Meanwhile, eldest daughter Coral (Sullivan) gets a job at a shark exhibit run by a salty fisherman (Schreiber) who has a connection with Shaz.

Writer-director Hogan packs the film with rude references to The Sound of Music, from a pastiche pre-title sequence to Shaz's unconventional Maria-like approach to child-rearing (with heavy overtones of Mary Poppins). The film is colourful and sometimes too hyperactive, with Collette often going way over-the-top as the wildly unhinged Shaz, who also upends the life of their compulsive next-door neighbour (Fox). Much of this is simply too wacky for us to go along with, but other scenes are quietly insightful and very, very funny. Often at the same time.

Intriguingly, Gibney and the young actresses playing her daughters are the only ones in the film who play it relatively straight. Everyone else is cartoonish, although even they let us see glimpses of the humans underneath. Some of the big set-pieces don't quite work (the action climax is badly botched), and several of the plot strands never develop properly. But Hogan and his cast manage to keep us entertained all the way through, and give us an offbeat look at mental health issues that's probably far more on the nose than most issue-based movies.

Rich Cline


Facts and Figures

Genre: Comedy

Run time: 116 mins

In Theaters: Friday 29th March 2013

Distributed by: Dada Films

Production compaines: Screen Australia

Reviews 3.5 / 5

Rotten Tomatoes: 40%
Fresh: 20 Rotten: 30

IMDB: 6.1 / 10

Cast & Crew


Producer: Todd Fellman, , ,

Starring: as Trevor Blundell, as Shaz, as Doris, as Barry Moochmore, as Nancy, as Shirley Moochmore, Lily Sullivan as Coral Moochmore, as Sandra, Natasha Bassett as Kay, Sam Clark as Trout, Malorie O'Neill as Michelle Moochmore, Bethany Whitmore as Jane Moochmore, as Jean, Chelsea Bennett as Kayleen Moochmore, Amanda Woodhams as Manda