THE CLEARING

"Weak"

THE CLEARING Review


One simple thing a filmmaker can do to make a picture better is to clearly establish time and place. You'd think that such a thing would be a given, but it's surprising how many filmmakers disregard this simple concept.

For the new film "The Clearing," writer Justin Haythe and writer/director Pieter Jan Brugge (a producer on "Bulworth," The Insider" and other films, making his directorial debut) probably intended to play with time, to bend it and stretch it to serve their purposes. But in the end, they only serve to alienate us by deliberately confusing us.

The film begins like a standard-issue kidnapping story, similar to 2000's "Proof of Life" and a dozen others. The filmmakers cut back and forth between the kidnap victim and his fretting wife, trying to build an equal amount of suspense within each storyline.

A car-rental tycoon, Wayne Hayes (Robert Redford), lives comfortably with his wife Eileen (Helen Mirren) until a creepy kidnapper (Willem Dafoe) snatches him out of his driveway one morning. (We know he's a creepy kidnapper because he slicks down his hair and wears a short-sleeve, button-down shirt.) He records a "honey I'm fine" message on a tape and they head for the woods, where they begin walking.

This thoughtful kidnapper provides Wayne with a pair of comfortable walking shoes and even brings sandwiches and cigarettes. As we would expect from a Hollywood film, Wayne begins trying to psychologically badger his captor, attempting to call his bluff.

At home, the film's timeline begins to skew. Eileen receives items in the mail, causing us to wonder -- from where in the woods did the kidnapper mail this? How did it arrive in less than one day?

Things get even muddier when the kidnapper's demand comes in for $9.5 million worth of diamonds and half a million in cash. He gives Eileen three days to come up with it, and she does. Have the kidnapper and Wayne been walking through the woods for three days with only a couple of sandwiches to sustain them? Or did Eileen gather up the diamonds in less than one day?

It turns out that the filmmakers do have an agenda, but it's not as surprising or as clever as you may think. And the skewed timeline reveals everything anyway.

The basic problem comes not with the timeline, but with the dual storylines. In "Proof of Life," kidnap victim David Morse carried the film, while the silly romance between fretting wife Meg Ryan and hostage negotiator Russell Crowe only slowed things down.

But in a superb film like George Sluizer's "The Vanishing" -- the 1988 Dutch original, not the 1993 American remake -- we follow the victim's family, getting to the kidnapper only late in the game. We share in their frustration of not knowing, and only being able to imagine the horrors their loved one might be going through.

Directorially, Brugge attempts to create an atmosphere of quiet dread similar to "The Vanishing," but he fails to use some of his most basic weapons. The woods could have been used for extraordinary visual designs, illustrating terror or claustrophobia. But instead he opts for endless close-ups of his actors as they sweat and get dirty. It's more tiresome than suspenseful.

Ultimately, "The Clearing" is one of those movies that inspires a "what were they thinking?" response. Why would such a great actress as Mirren want to play a nothing "victim" role after her brilliant long-running turn as a homicide detective on "Prime Suspect"? And why would the accomplished Dafoe want to play yet another slimy creep?

As for Redford, I have a feeling that this screenplay and its non-traditional ending may have inspired in him some nostalgia for the 1970s -- when they actually made brave films from time to time. Unfortunately "The Clearing" is not so much brave as it is transparent.



THE CLEARING

Facts and Figures

Run time: 95 mins

In Theaters: Thursday 23rd December 2004

Box Office USA: $5.6M

Box Office Worldwide: $12.5M

Distributed by: Fox Searchlight Pictures

Production compaines: Fox Searchlight Pictures

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 2 / 5

Rotten Tomatoes: 43%
Fresh: 56 Rotten: 75

IMDB: 5.9 / 10

Cast & Crew

Starring: as Wayne Hayes, as Eileen Hayes, as Arnold Mack, as Tim Hayes, as Agent Ray Fuller, as Jill Hayes

Also starring:

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Jackie Movie Review

Jackie Movie Review

Rather than make a standard biopic about the most famous First Lady in American history,...

Split Movie Review

Split Movie Review

After a few badly received sci-fi blockbusters, M. Night Shyamalan returned to his earthier style...

xXx: Return of Xander Cage Movie Review

xXx: Return of Xander Cage Movie Review

It's been 15 years since Vin Diesel walked away from his XXX role, killing off...

Manchester by the Sea Movie Review

Manchester by the Sea Movie Review

This may not be the cheeriest movie of the season, but it's so skilfully written,...

Live By Night Movie Review

Live By Night Movie Review

Ben Affleck launched his directing career 10 years ago with his film of Dennis Lehane's...

La La Land Movie Review

La La Land Movie Review

After storming awards season with Whiplash two years ago, writer-director Damien Chazelle returns with something...

Assassin's Creed Movie Review

Assassin's Creed Movie Review

Hopes were high that this film might finally crack the curse of movies based on...

Advertisement
Silence Movie Review

Silence Movie Review

Faith is a topic Martin Scorsese can't quite shake, courting controversy with complex films like...

A Monster Calls Movie Review

A Monster Calls Movie Review

A difficult movie to market, this isn't actually the BFG-style fantasy adventure it looks like....

Monster Trucks Movie Review

Monster Trucks Movie Review

Word has it that a 4-year-old came up with the idea for this unapologetically silly...

Collateral Beauty Movie Review

Collateral Beauty Movie Review

Dramas exploring the nature of death and the true meaning of life are always in...

Paterson Movie Review

Paterson Movie Review

Unpredictable filmmaker Jim Jarmusch ricochets from his artful vampire movie Only Lovers Left Alive into...

I, Daniel Blake Movie Review

I, Daniel Blake Movie Review

At 80 years old, British filmmaker Ken Loach won his second Cannes Film Festival with...

Why Him? Movie Review

Why Him? Movie Review

Writer-director John Hamburg continues to recycle the formula that made his first hit Meet the...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.